Kill the "SPY" BUG = Grow the war clans

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SharkyFinn

It's possible what you say could be true, but the current loophole keeps clans from admitting new members or visitors for fear of being taken advantage of. I say we close this loophole and look at or deal with others down the road. More interactions between players should be encouraged and the spying loophole discourages them.

---

I like your response.
I think maybe a waiting list feature might help.recruiting from global or using feeder clans is the best way to not to recruit spies.

Dear Zelonius, If game is updated to SHOW a MEMBER-LEVEL player exactly what the ENEMY CLAN SEES !, then there will be no usefulness of a spy anymore !

So, I don't think there would be ANY further work required on this issue anymore.

We must look at the larger picture of Clans not able to grow due to this problem and players not finding good clans to join !

Unfortunately there will be other ways for people to spy and once supercell takes one little tiny step to deter spying the floodgates will open and people will push for all forms of spying to be stopped.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zelonius

Unfortunately there will be other ways for people to spy and once supercell takes one little tiny step to deter spying the floodgates will open and people will push for all forms of spying to be stopped.

---

Let me ask, What are the other ways?

Viewing previous wars is one way....im sure there are other ways as well

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jaibansal24

I run a war clan level-10 with daily wars

Situation: We keep clan on "Invite Only" or "Closed", to avoid enemy "SPY" from becoming a member and knowing our war-bases' traps.

Problem: As a result, we are not able grow our clan. When clan is "Open", many new people keep coming and we can Recruit easily. But since we have wars "Back-to-Back", we never get new members :(

Solution = Any clan members who are "Member-only" Should NOT BE ABLE TO SEE THE TRAPS !!
i.e. only Elders, Co-Leaders, Leader can see friendly war-bases' Traps !

Result: So, we can leave over clan as "OPEN" all the time, and just not promote any new-comer for 1-2 days.
Clans will grow easily + Players will find more Open Clans to join = Better growth for both the game and the gamers !!

---

1. Keep your Clan Invite Only. You wouldn't want intruders.
2. Only people that joined the Clan after the War's start shouldn't be able to see the Traps.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zelonius

Viewing previous wars is one way....im sure there are other ways as well

---

Good Point ! But it will not be very precise and 100% complete (atleast for higher TH bases, which often don't get 100%)

And then we can't just sit and let a wrong thing happen just bcoz there can be other (less efficient) ways to do the wrong.

For people who join after war has started :
1. Hide Traps
2. Hide previous war's Replays !

Any other spying ways you can think of ?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Paladin95

1. Keep your Clan Invite Only. You wouldn't want intruders.
2. Only people that joined the Clan after the War's start shouldn't be able to see the Traps.

---

1. HAVING TO keep the clan on "Invite-Only or Closed" ITSELF IS THE PROBLEM that we are discussing.

2. Yes ! And we can also have feature that they can automatically start seeing traps, only AFTER 48 hours of joining a clan ! (Unless manually PROMOTED to Elder)

Seconded... BUMP!

What about the clan members that actually want to see the war attacks, and not cheat?