Kill the "SPY" BUG = Grow the war clans

I run a war clan level-10 with daily wars

Situation: We keep clan on "Invite Only" or "Closed", to avoid enemy "SPY" from becoming a member and knowing our war-bases' traps.

Problem: As a result, we are not able grow our clan. When clan is "Open", many new people keep coming and we can Recruit easily. But since we have wars "Back-to-Back", we never get new members :(

Solution = Any clan members who are "Member-only" Should NOT BE ABLE TO SEE THE TRAPS !!
i.e. only Elders, Co-Leaders, Leader can see friendly war-bases' Traps !

Result: So, we can leave over clan as "OPEN" all the time, and just not promote any new-comer for 1-2 days.
Clans will grow easily + Players will find more Open Clans to join = Better growth for both the game and the gamers !!

This and variations have been requested many times. For example, people with the NEW status should not be able to click on the War icon. Simple, easy to implement, not done.

yest this must be implemented - its a great idea. pls pls pls supercell respond.

Agreed. I've never understood why spying is still permitted. Even if it weren't a little underhanded and not really in-line with the family friendly atmosphere, it really hampers the social aspect since it cuts down on players moving between clans.

Great idea, should have been implemented yesterday.

Yes. Do it, Supercell.

I actually had an idea that Spectators can't see the bases or replays during war until after it ends.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SharkyFinn

it really hampers the social aspect since it cuts down on players moving between clans.

---

You are onto something there, an aspect I'd never thought before to raise and I am sure every clan currently closed or invite only would agree - its killing social movements.

Hi Supercell - can you make your game a friendlier sociable game by effectively locking new comers out of the war screen? We would all be more inclined to let strangers in during war day.
If one of current clan leaves to go to the sister clan and rejoins - simple give them their clan status back to enter the war screen. Or I am sure - you can also detect if this is a war participant to let them in anyway.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MasterCal

I actually had an idea that Spectators can't see the bases or replays during war until after it ends.

---

But please not this - As a leader I want to see the war attacks. Sometimes I may be out of the wars due to hero upgrades - don't lock me out as a spectator.

Also, some less experienced members can really learn from watching attacks - not always the same hours later. Watch live, ask questions of the person doing the attack the minute they finish.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrSteveSomething

But please not this - As a leader I want to see the war attacks. Sometimes I may be out of the wars due to hero upgrades - don't lock me out as a spectator.

Also, some less experienced members can really learn from watching attacks - not always the same hours later. Watch live, ask questions of the person doing the attack the minute they finish.

---

I agree to the 2nd para