Kicking clan member change

Many clans experience when they give elder quickly (1 min.- to 12 hours) and this elder kicks all the members. They can trick people by high trophies, friend to invite, or just on a whim. I call this clan raiding. Well, to prevent this limit the ability of the elder to kick people for no reason. One way is to make all non leader kicks approved by the leader when he gets on or at least approved by a couple of other elder via a chat option. Leaders still get the option to kick when they choose. This will keep clan raiders from being able to go on a rampage and kick all members. This will keep new clans from being hurt by shiny crystals with a death wish for them! Thanks for your time


*******Option also would be since elders approve some kicks through chat, you could make the option for elders could kick another elder through a vote too. ( elders now can only be kicked by leader )*****

Please respond with thoughts!

*********option thought via chat "invite the kicked back ,but only the leader can invite them back" *****

******option to limit kicks per day to 3 or so. Or the ability to mute in clan chat!**********

*******option to have a x number of hours before elders can start kicking**********

More ideas will be added keep them up! Plus share you stories of clan raiders!

I think from several comments that it may not be clear that the idea i am putting fourth would not hurt larger clans because all you need to kick people with is another elder's or leader's okay. This will save new clans described above and est. clan from kicking on accident.

This is an exsample of clan raiding:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nikito

Well hello, this is the third time a clan member that i promote to elder kicks out lots of members.. i know that its imposible to prevent this kind of behavior, bcos of the clan system that the game has, so the point of this post its at least to get revenge and try to ban the *** of ******** that kicked my members.
So well maybe any more experienced member of the forum can help me .. or a mod contact me or something!


Thanks in advance.

---

Super Cell thank you for addressing the problem in the new issue! If this thread had anything to do with it please post something it would really make me happy!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by texasrangerfan1998

Many clans experience when they give elder quickly (1 min.- to 12 hours) and this elder kicks all the members. They can trick people by high trophies, friend to invite, or just on a whim. I call this clan raiding. Well, to prevent this limit the ability of the elder to kick people for no reason. One way is to make all non leader kicks approved by the leader when he gets on or at least approved by a couple of other elder via a chat option. Leaders still get the option to kick when they choose. This will keep clan raiders from being able to go on a rampage and kick all members. This will keep new clans from being hurt by shiny crystals with a death wish for them! Thanks for your time


*******Option also would be since elders approve some kicks through chat, you could make the option for elders could kick another elder through a vote too. ( elders now can only be kicked by leader )*****

Please respond with thoughts!

---

this is good but would work all the time because elders arent on 24/7. so what if an elder wants to kik someone who is being annoying and disturbing the clan members? he couldnt kick without another elder on. i was thinknig maybe put a cool down on the kicking. so an elder only gets 3 kicks per day or something like that

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by swagtastic2323

this is good but would work all the time because elders arent on 24/7. so what if an elder wants to kik someone who is being annoying and disturbing the clan members? he couldnt kick without another elder on. i was thinknig maybe put a cool down on the kicking. so an elder only gets 3 kicks per day or something like that

---

See your point maybe open the kicking poll to members too. Five members plus a elder equals kick! If not that maybe that is the price to pay for the death of clan raiding.

If you don't want people kicking/promoting, don't give out elder :p

That would screw up the regular kicking here's a grand idea don't give new ppl elder!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nats11

If you don't want people kicking/promoting, don't give out elder :p

---

I think super cell hurts new clans that don't realize the power of the elder. This would protect growing clans, while not really penalizing the better ones.

Another way to ,make it safe is make everyone elder,no one can raging and kick everybody.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilverSky

Another way to ,make it safe is make everyone elder,no one can raging and kick everybody.

---

If everyone elder, no is elder, but that is one way to do it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Archers

That would screw up the regular kicking here's a grand idea don't give new ppl elder!

---

How can people do that unless they learn or you do what I said. It wouldn't hurt you and help others!

---

Thank you for your help

Or SC could make it that a new elder can't kick for the first x number of hours after being given the promotion.

I had this idea but if the elder just do a simple majority, the person gets out but they can suggest to the leader that this person will be kicked out..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheRulingEmperor

I had this idea but if the elder just do a simple majority, the person gets out but they can suggest to the leader that this person will be kicked out..

---

The way how is not a big deal for me. My idea still gives power to the leader but ur idea has merit

I believe that if Clash of Clans were to limit the kickout option to a low number per hour for each elder this would stem the breakup of clans. An example would be to limit one elder to a max of 5 kickouts per hour. This would create a window for other elders and the clan leader to address the problem before facing a loss of all members. If more people need to get the boot, then elders can team up to accomplish this. Clan leader of course would retain rights to kick as many people as needed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dolo

I believe that if Clash of Clans were to limit the kickout option to a low number per hour for each elder this would stem the breakup of clans. An example would be to limit one elder to a max of 5 kickouts per hour. This would create a window for other elders and the clan leader to address the problem before facing a loss of all members. If more people need to get the boot, then elders can team up to accomplish this. Clan leader of course would retain rights to kick as many people as needed.

---

I have seen people try hit at night when everyone is asleep! They could hit 15-20 times before u realize. My way would save the possible 5+ players that got kicked. I think your way is possible but I think my way limits it better to stop the real problem clan raiding!

An other way you could try to fix this issue is by letting you invite players that have been kicked.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RICHYRICH

An other way you could try to fix this issue is by letting you invite players that have been kicked.

---

It would be nice to be able to give an invite to kicked/left people. But that can of invite only done by the leader maybe?

Just show that some one saw it thanks!

what u said is great, but also the leader should be able to give the kicking power to elders permanently if they trust them and a co-leader rank which can kick elders, but not other co-leaders or the leader

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FlyingGolem1337

what u said is great, but also the leader should be able to give the kicking power to elders permanently if they trust them and a co-leader rank which can kick elders, but not other co-leaders or the leader

---

Co leaders a great idea. Having the ability to give a person that rank should be limited to 3 or can only be give after one secession.

When we are trophy pushing or recruiting, we may get several requests to join per day. And by several I mean 20-30. We screen members for age and maturity- the only real way to do this is chat with them. Some leave politely when we explain the age limit, that requesting immediately is a big no no, and elder is earned. Others start arguing, whining, start name-calling, etc. we may find 1 out of every 20 that fit our clan. Limiting our ability to kick would only hurt our clan. The only time we had problems with a rogue elder was when an elder accidentally hit promote instead of kick. The other elders quickly promoted everyone and we only lost a couple.

This hopper/rogue elder deal is a management problem of leaders and elders, not a game issue. To impose new rules only hurts established clans. There are a lot of in-game features there that allow you to control who does what in your clan. Use them well and this really isnt an issue.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Becca74

When we are trophy pushing or recruiting, we may get several requests to join per day. And by several I mean 20-30. We screen members for age and maturity- the only real way to do this is chat with them. Some leave politely when we explain the age limit, that requesting immediately is a big no no, and elder is earned. Others start arguing, whining, start name-calling, etc. we may find 1 out of every 20 that fit our clan. Limiting our ability to kick would only hurt our clan. The only time we had problems with a rogue elder was when an elder accidentally hit promote instead of kick. The other elders quickly promoted everyone and we only lost a couple.

This hopper/rogue elder deal is a management problem of leaders and elders, not a game issue. To impose new rules only hurts established clans. There are a lot of in-game features there that allow you to control who does what in your clan. Use them well and this really isnt an issue.

---

My idea would not hurt the est. clans at all. In your example you have at least two elders screening and that would be all you need to kick possibly. This idea saves the small clan and make the est. clans be just slightly less likely to kick people by accident. So your example is invalid because it really doesn't have any real problem with a least two elders to kick people.

I have this problem, let them stay for a week then give them elder, or just make everyone elder

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jimbob2000

I have this problem, let them stay for a week then give them elder, or just make everyone elder

---

If supercell was to not adapt my idea, what u said is the best way to combat clan raiding now.


the more views save more clan quickier

Please tell your stories of clan raiders hitting your clan.

My clan pilfering bums were raided for 5 people in May. By nathan18+ who got banned after a report to sc.

Live with it

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jimbob2000

Live with it

---

What a bad attitude😒!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Becca74

When we are trophy pushing or recruiting, we may get several requests to join per day. And by several I mean 20-30. We screen members for age and maturity- the only real way to do this is chat with them. Some leave politely when we explain the age limit, that requesting immediately is a big no no, and elder is earned. Others start arguing, whining, start name-calling, etc. we may find 1 out of every 20 that fit our clan. Limiting our ability to kick would only hurt our clan. The only time we had problems with a rogue elder was when an elder accidentally hit promote instead of kick. The other elders quickly promoted everyone and we only lost a couple.

This hopper/rogue elder deal is a management problem of leaders and elders, not a game issue. To impose new rules only hurts established clans. There are a lot of in-game features there that allow you to control who does what in your clan. Use them well and this really isnt an issue.

---

Thank you its not super cells job to micro manage everyone's clan and make sure their elders aren't rogue just because of people's bad judgement. If you don't want a rogue elder just promote the most mature members that tend not to ask for it not blame supercell and point fingers because of ur lack of judgement. I agree 100% with Becca

My old clan was destroyed by a rogue elder but u don't see me crying about it. It was another elder's fault because he promoted his 'friend' from global who went and kicked all members. All that I learned was that don't give elder to idiots or people who just joined just because they are a TH9/10 or in Crystal/Master League.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DakotaDeal

Thank you its not super cells job to micro manage everyone's clan and make sure their elders aren't rogue just because of people's bad judgement. If you don't want a rogue elder just promote the most mature members that tend not to ask for it not blame supercell and point fingers because of ur lack of judgement. I agree 100% with Becca

---

Looking out for the little guy is no bad. You gave no reason it would not work. Only that you don't care about clan raiders! This helps mature clans from not kicking people by accident. I am not saying super cell should review every kick request just that another elder or the leaders agree with the kick instead of instantly kicking them. Why don't you like the idea not the fact you want to hurt small clans!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by texasrangerfan1998

Looking out for the little guy is no bad. You gave no reason it would not work. Only that you don't care about clan raiders! This helps mature clans from not kicking people by accident. I am not saying super cell should review every kick request just that another elder or the leaders agree with the kick instead of instantly kicking them. Why don't you like the idea not the fact you want to hurt small clans!

---

No I'd just rather see supercell spend their time in more important updates and not waste space on people's poor judgement. I'd much rather see a construction mode, clan wars, clan ranks, and i can go on much better updates then this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DakotaDeal

No I'd just rather see supercell spend their time in more important updates and not waste space on people's poor judgement. I'd much rather see a construction mode, clan wars, clan ranks, and i can go on much better updates then this.

---

This update would take them a day maybe! It would improve the game experience and keep young gem buyers from rage quitting by getting their new clan destroyed by a mistake that sc doesn't warn about! Improving the game experience is just as important as new options!😃

They can just add a feature to invite members who were kicked or left and it'll be fine. No need to mess it up for others

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrX

They can just add a feature to invite members who were kicked or left and it'll be fine. No need to mess it up for others

---

Though I disagree it hurts everyone else. Your idea is a quick way to fix most of the problem!😀

😀😀😃With a few tweaks this idea could soar!😃😀😀

Read sticky it has a time option request already and it is better

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Streamshot004

Read sticky it has a time option request already and it is better

---

More we do and talk to stop clan raiders the better! The "read the sticky" is the laziest comment can make too.

I will try to respond to all comments made

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by texasrangerfan1998

Many clans experience when they give elder quickly (1 min.- to 12 hours) and this elder kicks all the members. They can trick people by high trophies, friend to invite, or just on a whim. I call this clan raiding. Well, to prevent this limit the ability of the elder to kick people for no reason. One way is to make all non leader kicks approved by the leader when he gets on or at least approved by a couple of other elder via a chat option. Leaders still get the option to kick when they choose. This will keep clan raiders from being able to go on a rampage and kick all members. This will keep new clans from being hurt by shiny crystals with a death wish for them! Thanks for your time


*******Option also would be since elders approve some kicks through chat, you could make the option for elders could kick another elder through a vote too. ( elders now can only be kicked by leader )*****

Please respond with thoughts!

*********option thought via chat "invite the kicked back ,but only the leader can invite them back" *****

******option to limit kicks per day to 3 or so. Or the ability to mute in clan chat!**********

More ideas will be added keep them up! Plus share you stories of clan raiders!

I think from several comments that it may not be clear that the idea i am putting fourth would not hurt larger clans because all you need to kick people with is another elder's or leader's okay. This will save new clans described above and est. clan from kicking on accident.

---

Anyone have any thoughts?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by texasrangerfan1998

Anyone have any thoughts?

---

Yes I have one.....bumping is not allowed in the forums..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheRulingEmperor

Yes I have one.....bumping is not allowed in the forums..

---

I just wanted to make sure everyone got a chance to put their opinion in.:eek:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RICHYRICH

Or SC could make it that a new elder can't kick for the first x number of hours after being given the promotion.

---

Cool down period would be nice. Definatitly an option!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by texasrangerfan1998

Many clans experience when they give elder quickly (1 min.- to 12 hours) and this elder kicks all the members. They can trick people by high trophies, friend to invite, or just on a whim. I call this clan raiding. Well, to prevent this limit the ability of the elder to kick people for no reason. One way is to make all non leader kicks approved by the leader when he gets on or at least approved by a couple of other elder via a chat option. Leaders still get the option to kick when they choose. This will keep clan raiders from being able to go on a rampage and kick all members. This will keep new clans from being hurt by shiny crystals with a death wish for them! Thanks for your time


*******Option also would be since elders approve some kicks through chat, you could make the option for elders could kick another elder through a vote too. ( elders now can only be kicked by leader )*****

Please respond with thoughts!

*********option thought via chat "invite the kicked back ,but only the leader can invite them back" *****

******option to limit kicks per day to 3 or so. Or the ability to mute in clan chat!**********

*******option to have a x number of hours before elders can start kicking**********

More ideas will be added keep them up! Plus share you stories of clan raiders!

I think from several comments that it may not be clear that the idea i am putting fourth would not hurt larger clans because all you need to kick people with is another elder's or leader's okay. This will save new clans described above and est. clan from kicking on accident.

---

gd idea but think if the leader wasnt on to approve to the kick and there was a guy saying bad words etc and cant be tolerated 1 more min what should they do?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aldo20

gd idea but think if the leader wasnt on to approve to the kick and there was a guy saying bad words etc and cant be tolerated 1 more min what should they do?

---

I think they should impalment the ability to mute the player in clan or make it were all you need is the approval of another elder or a group of elders. Thanks for input and the question!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by texasrangerfan1998

See your point maybe open the kicking poll to members too. Five members plus a elder equals kick! If not that maybe that is the price to pay for the death of clan raiding.

---

Should members be able to kick other members?

How about, don't give out Elder....:D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Unknown00TS

How about, don't give out Elder....:D

---

Why not make the change? Stops accidental kicks and helps the small guy! Please give a solution next time!

Make all elder, then only leader can kick :D
Or make None as Elder.

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-kick%21%21%21


I suggested the same in a thread earlier on....I AGREE ON THIS AND HOPED SUPERCELL CAN LOOK INTO THIS! Anyway elders are in the clan to 'police' and help leader....so they should not be able to kick everyone! It should be limited to kicking 1 person per 12 hours!

the best option will be limit elders to be able to kick 1 person per 12 hours...or to remove this function totally!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by texasrangerfan1998

Many clans experience when they give elder quickly (1 min.- to 12 hours) and this elder kicks all the members. They can trick people by high trophies, friend to invite, or just on a whim. I call this clan raiding. Well, to prevent this limit the ability of the elder to kick people for no reason. One way is to make all non leader kicks approved by the leader when he gets on or at least approved by a couple of other elder via a chat option. Leaders still get the option to kick when they choose. This will keep clan raiders from being able to go on a rampage and kick all members. This will keep new clans from being hurt by shiny crystals with a death wish for them! Thanks for your time


*******Option also would be since elders approve some kicks through chat, you could make the option for elders could kick another elder through a vote too. ( elders now can only be kicked by leader )*****

Please respond with thoughts!

*********option thought via chat "invite the kicked back ,but only the leader can invite them back" *****

******option to limit kicks per day to 3 or so. Or the ability to mute in clan chat!**********

*******option to have a x number of hours before elders can start kicking**********

More ideas will be added keep them up! Plus share you stories of clan raiders!

I think from several comments that it may not be clear that the idea i am putting fourth would not hurt larger clans because all you need to kick people with is another elder's or leader's okay. This will save new clans described above and est. clan from kicking on accident.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bompipi

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-kick%21%21%21


I suggested the same in a thread earlier on....I AGREE ON THIS AND HOPED SUPERCELL CAN LOOK INTO THIS! Anyway elders are in the clan to 'police' and help leader....so they should not be able to kick everyone! It should be limited to kicking 1 person per 12 hours!

the best option will be limit elders to be able to kick 1 person per 12 hours...or to remove this function totally!

---

You get it! 1 for 12 hours is reasonable too. Elders should be police not mass cearl killers.

Well hello, this is the third time a clan member that i promote to elder kicks out lots of members.. i know that its imposible to prevent this kind of behavior, bcos of the clan system that the game has, so the point of this post its at least to get revenge and try to ban the s*n of ******** that kicked my members.
So well maybe any more experienced member of the forum can help me .. or a mod contact me or something!

Thanks in advance.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Becca74

When we are trophy pushing or recruiting, we may get several requests to join per day. And by several I mean 20-30. We screen members for age and maturity- the only real way to do this is chat with them. Some leave politely when we explain the age limit, that requesting immediately is a big no no, and elder is earned. Others start arguing, whining, start name-calling, etc. we may find 1 out of every 20 that fit our clan. Limiting our ability to kick would only hurt our clan. The only time we had problems with a rogue elder was when an elder accidentally hit promote instead of kick. The other elders quickly promoted everyone and we only lost a couple.

This hopper/rogue elder deal is a management problem of leaders and elders, not a game issue. To impose new rules only hurts established clans. There are a lot of in-game features there that allow you to control who does what in your clan. Use them well and this really isnt an issue.

---

This is definitely a game issue. First u r lucky the elders in ur clan reacted fast n promote everyone quickly. Second, u can't control a loyal active elder who decided to go crazy one day n kick everyone out.
if the game limits the kicking to 1-2 per day then it will not have such a problem...I have spoken to many leaders n they all face such agony.... Elder went crazy starts kicking...in the end they promote everyone to elder which I find it lame...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nikito

Well hello, this is the third time a clan member that i promote to elder kicks out lots of members.. i know that its imposible to prevent this kind of behavior, bcos of the clan system that the game has, so the point of this post its at least to get revenge and try to ban the s*n of ******** that kicked my members.
So well maybe any more experienced member of the forum can help me .. or a mod contact me or something!

Thanks in advance.

---

I understand your agony it happened to me once n to my friend twice....it is very frustrating when u built up the clan from zero n this joker whose has been loyal n v active started kicking everyone out without warning....so supercell please look into limiting elder function to kick!!

I have made a similiar post earlier on on this issue

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-kick%21%21%21

We have had our clan terrorized so many times by something like this.... This option would be awesome!!!! The last time i had literally ran to my car to get my dinner and in less than 5 min a person that had been in our clan multiple weeks kicked 15 people!!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilverSky

Another way to ,make it safe is make everyone elder,no one can raging and kick everybody.

---

True, but if you have a Invite only clan, and someone requests access to the clan, you have elders rejecting... happened to my clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nikito

Well hello, this is the third time a clan member that i promote to elder kicks out lots of members.. i know that its imposible to prevent this kind of behavior, bcos of the clan system that the game has, so the point of this post its at least to get revenge and try to ban the s*n of ******** that kicked my members.
So well maybe any more experienced member of the forum can help me .. or a mod contact me or something!

Thanks in advance.

---

This is a problem that supercell never warns about! It is an instant thing that should be limited. I had the same thing happen to my clan. This kind of story really shows why it is nessiary to implement the changes described above.

They just need a cooldown for when an elder kicks a clan member. the cooldown time should be set by the clan leader. Or there can be settings that allow the leader to pick and choose which elders can kick clan members or if any elders have the power to kick people also a setting for how many members an elder can kick before the cooldown begins

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SuicideBlitz

They just need a cooldown for when an elder kicks a clan member. the cooldown time should be set by the clan leader. Or there can be settings that allow the leader to pick and choose which elders can kick clan members or if any elders have the power to kick people also a setting for how many members an elder can kick before the cooldown begins

---

Cool down is an option. Thanks for your opinion!

This is a long thread so I'm not sure if this idea was already put out there, but what about a system similar to the reporting system on global so 2-5 elders can stop another elder from kicking for a certain amount of time?

no.. with a simply report the clan riding will continue... bcos once the act happens then you report it.. so you lost all the members.. thats not a solution.. not even temporal..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nikito

no.. with a simply report the clan riding will continue... bcos once the act happens then you report it.. so you lost all the members.. thats not a solution.. not even temporal..

---

I agree reporting it really doesn't stop the issue, unless the report instantly shut their account down. And the members can't be gotten back.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by texasrangerfan1998

Many clans experience when they give elder quickly (1 min.- to 12 hours) and this elder kicks all the members. They can trick people by high trophies, friend to invite, or just on a whim. I call this clan raiding. Well, to prevent this limit the ability of the elder to kick people for no reason. One way is to make all non leader kicks approved by the leader when he gets on or at least approved by a couple of other elder via a chat option. Leaders still get the option to kick when they choose. This will keep clan raiders from being able to go on a rampage and kick all members. This will keep new clans from being hurt by shiny crystals with a death wish for them! Thanks for your time


*******Option also would be since elders approve some kicks through chat, you could make the option for elders could kick another elder through a vote too. ( elders now can only be kicked by leader )*****

Please respond with thoughts!

*********option thought via chat "invite the kicked back ,but only the leader can invite them back" *****

******option to limit kicks per day to 3 or so. Or the ability to mute in clan chat!**********

*******option to have a x number of hours before elders can start kicking**********

More ideas will be added keep them up! Plus share you stories of clan raiders!

I think from several comments that it may not be clear that the idea i am putting fourth would not hurt larger clans because all you need to kick people with is another elder's or leader's okay. This will save new clans described above and est. clan from kicking on accident.

This is an exsample of clan raiding:



There is the proof of a problem!!!

---

Yes definetley. Good idea.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ClasherOfClans

Yes definetley. Good idea.

---

Thanks your support! You have helped to kill the clan raiding fools who hurt this game!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Slab67

This is a long thread so I'm not sure if this idea was already put out there, but what about a system similar to the reporting system on global so 2-5 elders can stop another elder from kicking for a certain amount of time?

---

U could do this now by reporting them to supercell through email.

There should be option that only chosen elders can kick.
Or an option that you can only invite and accept other people, so only the leader can choose who is authorised to kick!

Our clan, which has been playing continuously for over 6 months, has just had an extremely trusted elder kick many members.

This is not the first time for our clan, it's happened over 3 times. Once early on, because we were newbies (6 months ago). Once because senior elders go into a fight, and decided to kick. Luckily, the leader me, was able to stop the elder kick before it happened.

And now, most recently, a trusted elder from the original joining group, decided to rage kick clan. To the people saying that you need to trust elder, etc, it's just a matter of time.

It's completely strange: if you have an elder earned system where you trust just a few people, then you are extremely vulnerable to one of those people kicking everyone. It's extremely disruptive to put clan together.

Also, there's no reason an elder should be kicking more than 1 person per day.

The elder/leader system is broken, and needs to be fixed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fluorodeoxyglucose

Our clan, which has been playing continuously for over 6 months, has just had an extremely trusted elder kick many members.

This is not the first time for our clan, it's happened over 3 times. Once early on, because we were newbies (6 months ago). Once because senior elders go into a fight, and decided to kick. Luckily, the leader me, was able to stop the elder kick before it happened.

And now, most recently, a trusted elder from the original joining group, decided to rage kick clan. To the people saying that you need to trust elder, etc, it's just a matter of time.

It's completely strange: if you have an elder earned system where you trust just a few people, then you are extremely vulnerable to one of those people kicking everyone. It's extremely disruptive to put clan together.

Also, there's no reason an elder should be kicking more than 1 person per day.

The elder/leader system is broken, and needs to be fixed.

---

I agree about the system is broken and this is an option to fix it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by playerA19V98

There should be option that only chosen elders can kick.
Or an option that you can only invite and accept other people, so only the leader can choose who is authorised to kick!

---

Agreed on the premise

Cool down is a great way to stop the clan raiding

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by texasrangerfan1998

If everyone elder, no is elder, but that is one way to do it.

---

When you are a member you can't invite so there is a point in making everybody elder.

Supercell actually already made it so elders have a cool down time for kicking, so this is fixed as of today