Kicking clan member change
Many clans experience when they give elder quickly (1 min.- to 12 hours) and this elder kicks all the members. They can trick people by high trophies, friend to invite, or just on a whim. I call this clan raiding. Well, to prevent this limit the ability of the elder to kick people for no reason. One way is to make all non leader kicks approved by the leader when he gets on or at least approved by a couple of other elder via a chat option. Leaders still get the option to kick when they choose. This will keep clan raiders from being able to go on a rampage and kick all members. This will keep new clans from being hurt by shiny crystals with a death wish for them! Thanks for your time
*******Option also would be since elders approve some kicks through chat, you could make the option for elders could kick another elder through a vote too. ( elders now can only be kicked by leader )*****
Please respond with thoughts!
*********option thought via chat "invite the kicked back ,but only the leader can invite them back" *****
******option to limit kicks per day to 3 or so. Or the ability to mute in clan chat!**********
*******option to have a x number of hours before elders can start kicking**********
More ideas will be added keep them up! Plus share you stories of clan raiders!
I think from several comments that it may not be clear that the idea i am putting fourth would not hurt larger clans because all you need to kick people with is another elder's or leader's okay. This will save new clans described above and est. clan from kicking on accident.
This is an exsample of clan raiding:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Nikito
Well hello, this is the third time a clan member that i promote to elder kicks out lots of members.. i know that its imposible to prevent this kind of behavior, bcos of the clan system that the game has, so the point of this post its at least to get revenge and try to ban the *** of ******** that kicked my members.
So well maybe any more experienced member of the forum can help me .. or a mod contact me or something!
Thanks in advance.
Super Cell thank you for addressing the problem in the new issue! If this thread had anything to do with it please post something it would really make me happy!
Just don't give randoms elder
That would screw up the regular kicking here's a grand idea don't give new ppl elder!
Supercell has no warnings against that!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Archers
That would screw up the regular kicking here's a grand idea don't give new ppl elder!
How can people do that unless they learn or you do what I said. It wouldn't hurt you and help others!
Anyone like it or don't. please explain!
Elder voting to kick someone
I had this idea but if the elder just do a simple majority, the person gets out but they can suggest to the leader that this person will be kicked out..
Option for controlling rouge elders
I believe that if Clash of Clans were to limit the kickout option to a low number per hour for each elder this would stem the breakup of clans. An example would be to limit one elder to a max of 5 kickouts per hour. This would create a window for other elders and the clan leader to address the problem before facing a loss of all members. If more people need to get the boot, then elders can team up to accomplish this. Clan leader of course would retain rights to kick as many people as needed.
That is a good add on i think to my idea
Quote:
Originally Posted by
RICHYRICH
An other way you could try to fix this issue is by letting you invite players that have been kicked.
It would be nice to be able to give an invite to kicked/left people. But that can of invite only done by the leader maybe?
If a supercell official sees this thread please reply
Just show that some one saw it thanks!
Nice idea id like to add on tho
what u said is great, but also the leader should be able to give the kicking power to elders permanently if they trust them and a co-leader rank which can kick elders, but not other co-leaders or the leader
We want to save your brand new clan too!
Please tell your stories of clan raiders hitting your clan.
Then why do people complain about loot penalty
Quote:
Originally Posted by
DakotaDeal
Thank you its not super cells job to micro manage everyone's clan and make sure their elders aren't rogue just because of people's bad judgement. If you don't want a rogue elder just promote the most mature members that tend not to ask for it not blame supercell and point fingers because of ur lack of judgement. I agree 100% with Becca
Looking out for the little guy is no bad. You gave no reason it would not work. Only that you don't care about clan raiders! This helps mature clans from not kicking people by accident. I am not saying super cell should review every kick request just that another elder or the leaders agree with the kick instead of instantly kicking them. Why don't you like the idea not the fact you want to hurt small clans!
I think this is a good idea!
😀😀😃With a few tweaks this idea could soar!😃😀😀
2 Attachment(s)
It is the third time it happens :(
Well hello, this is the third time a clan member that i promote to elder kicks out lots of members.. i know that its imposible to prevent this kind of behavior, bcos of the clan system that the game has, so the point of this post its at least to get revenge and try to ban the s*n of ******** that kicked my members.
So well maybe any more experienced member of the forum can help me .. or a mod contact me or something!
Thanks in advance.
24 hour cooldown for elder kicking
Our clan, which has been playing continuously for over 6 months, has just had an extremely trusted elder kick many members.
This is not the first time for our clan, it's happened over 3 times. Once early on, because we were newbies (6 months ago). Once because senior elders go into a fight, and decided to kick. Luckily, the leader me, was able to stop the elder kick before it happened.
And now, most recently, a trusted elder from the original joining group, decided to rage kick clan. To the people saying that you need to trust elder, etc, it's just a matter of time.
It's completely strange: if you have an elder earned system where you trust just a few people, then you are extremely vulnerable to one of those people kicking everyone. It's extremely disruptive to put clan together.
Also, there's no reason an elder should be kicking more than 1 person per day.
The elder/leader system is broken, and needs to be fixed.