Kicking clan member change

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bompipi

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-kick%21%21%21


I suggested the same in a thread earlier on....I AGREE ON THIS AND HOPED SUPERCELL CAN LOOK INTO THIS! Anyway elders are in the clan to 'police' and help leader....so they should not be able to kick everyone! It should be limited to kicking 1 person per 12 hours!

the best option will be limit elders to be able to kick 1 person per 12 hours...or to remove this function totally!

---

You get it! 1 for 12 hours is reasonable too. Elders should be police not mass cearl killers.

Well hello, this is the third time a clan member that i promote to elder kicks out lots of members.. i know that its imposible to prevent this kind of behavior, bcos of the clan system that the game has, so the point of this post its at least to get revenge and try to ban the s*n of ******** that kicked my members.
So well maybe any more experienced member of the forum can help me .. or a mod contact me or something!

Thanks in advance.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Becca74

When we are trophy pushing or recruiting, we may get several requests to join per day. And by several I mean 20-30. We screen members for age and maturity- the only real way to do this is chat with them. Some leave politely when we explain the age limit, that requesting immediately is a big no no, and elder is earned. Others start arguing, whining, start name-calling, etc. we may find 1 out of every 20 that fit our clan. Limiting our ability to kick would only hurt our clan. The only time we had problems with a rogue elder was when an elder accidentally hit promote instead of kick. The other elders quickly promoted everyone and we only lost a couple.

This hopper/rogue elder deal is a management problem of leaders and elders, not a game issue. To impose new rules only hurts established clans. There are a lot of in-game features there that allow you to control who does what in your clan. Use them well and this really isnt an issue.

---

This is definitely a game issue. First u r lucky the elders in ur clan reacted fast n promote everyone quickly. Second, u can't control a loyal active elder who decided to go crazy one day n kick everyone out.
if the game limits the kicking to 1-2 per day then it will not have such a problem...I have spoken to many leaders n they all face such agony.... Elder went crazy starts kicking...in the end they promote everyone to elder which I find it lame...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nikito

Well hello, this is the third time a clan member that i promote to elder kicks out lots of members.. i know that its imposible to prevent this kind of behavior, bcos of the clan system that the game has, so the point of this post its at least to get revenge and try to ban the s*n of ******** that kicked my members.
So well maybe any more experienced member of the forum can help me .. or a mod contact me or something!

Thanks in advance.

---

I understand your agony it happened to me once n to my friend twice....it is very frustrating when u built up the clan from zero n this joker whose has been loyal n v active started kicking everyone out without warning....so supercell please look into limiting elder function to kick!!

I have made a similiar post earlier on on this issue

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-kick%21%21%21

We have had our clan terrorized so many times by something like this.... This option would be awesome!!!! The last time i had literally ran to my car to get my dinner and in less than 5 min a person that had been in our clan multiple weeks kicked 15 people!!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SilverSky

Another way to ,make it safe is make everyone elder,no one can raging and kick everybody.

---

True, but if you have a Invite only clan, and someone requests access to the clan, you have elders rejecting... happened to my clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nikito

Well hello, this is the third time a clan member that i promote to elder kicks out lots of members.. i know that its imposible to prevent this kind of behavior, bcos of the clan system that the game has, so the point of this post its at least to get revenge and try to ban the s*n of ******** that kicked my members.
So well maybe any more experienced member of the forum can help me .. or a mod contact me or something!

Thanks in advance.

---

This is a problem that supercell never warns about! It is an instant thing that should be limited. I had the same thing happen to my clan. This kind of story really shows why it is nessiary to implement the changes described above.

They just need a cooldown for when an elder kicks a clan member. the cooldown time should be set by the clan leader. Or there can be settings that allow the leader to pick and choose which elders can kick clan members or if any elders have the power to kick people also a setting for how many members an elder can kick before the cooldown begins

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SuicideBlitz

They just need a cooldown for when an elder kicks a clan member. the cooldown time should be set by the clan leader. Or there can be settings that allow the leader to pick and choose which elders can kick clan members or if any elders have the power to kick people also a setting for how many members an elder can kick before the cooldown begins

---

Cool down is an option. Thanks for your opinion!