Clan War Stars

There is an option in each player profile where it shows how many stars this player has scored.

Just a random thought wouldn't it be nice to have some + sign for expanding star wars and see against which Town hall bases in clan war this player has scored more ?

me and my mate were having argument on this couple of days ago. He is a max th10 but he always attacks Th9 bases in war = more stars ez, compared to a guy who attacks max Th10 every war. His total war stars are over 1600 at the moment.

I think this will be somewhat interesting to see the caliber of each CW player.

A good idea.
Does it reset when they join a new clan?

Tbh I can't see the point to this, if we are in a war It may be necessary for one of our higher th to attack a smaller one to get us the win, so why should they have a star, chart that could make them look bad for no reason

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rue73

Tbh I can't see the point to this, if we are in a war It may be necessary for one of our higher th to attack a smaller one to get us the win, so why should they have a star, chart that could make them look bad for no reason

---

i am talking about players who are always attacking Lower town halls to gain more stars.

and yes as per war situation you need players to attack as required. That is the reason i said we need some sort of plus sign to see where the player has scored more stars. And this does not mean that a good player will always attack 2 Town halls lower villages. Yes at times you need to attack lower town hall but not always and this is understandable.

The plus side of this, is war farmers in war farming leagues will artificially get better stats since they always attack their mirrors and then attack top base for loot.

Definitely would look better than someone helping out the clan by cleaning a lower a TH, even though they probably just used a Hero to get those stars.

Sounds interesting but I think it would be difficult to make this useful without being counter productive.

First reason is as stated above, a war player often needs to clean-up a TH below them, and this is particularly dependent on your place in the war map. Example, we currently have three TH9s in our clan, the bottom of the three is almost always given TH8 targets in war, a mixed blessing for him because it gives him less loot, but its great for the clan because we guarantee 6 stars against the enemy's top TH8s which our own TH8s might not be able to do reliably every time. I would not want him to be also penalised on his profile for helping the clan out.

Second issue is that as a more senior player, for example a TH10, it might be that most of your war stars came when you were a TH9 or a TH8 against other TH9s and 8s, so if that showed up on your profile it could look as if you were going to low. When in fact you weren't they were just historic.

I think its an interesting idea but doesn't really give me much value and I think it will cause problems.

I don't think this is a good idea. I'm the only TH10 in my clan, and we have 4-5 TH9s and 3-4 TH8s in every war. We only do 10v10. One of out TH9s attacks the enemy TH10 and tries to 2 star them. That's our strategy because all I'm ever going to get on a TH10 is 2 stars right now because I'm still somewhat new to TH10. 2 stars from a TH9 and 2 stars from a TH10 are still 2 stars on the war map. But It's much easier for me to 3 star 2 of the TH9s. So that's our strategy.

At the same time though, we had one guy who was a TH9 that ALWAYS attacked TH8s because he was just a terrible player. He failed to 3 star TH8s, even as a TH9. He was just that bad.

So indicating whether or not someone's war stars came from attacking equal, lower, or higher TH level doesn't explain much. When it comes to getting war stars, nobody cares who they came from as long as you have more stars than the other clan.