9 clan management ideas

• Add clan challenges (best monthly donator, best clan war star increase…) with incentive rewards & public clan announcements.

• New clan ranks.

• Automatically reward clan member loyalty as the time goes by (with increasing rewards).

• Ask for a deposit for being recruited in a clan war. If you don’t attack at all or do only one, you lose it all or half. Harder alternative : get paid back depending on how many stars you bring back.

• More clan description space.

• Allow to set a specific threshold a member (so not elders & co-leaders) must reach before being able for asking troops.

• Give us donators’ names or don’t allow donations other than those requested.

• Send a clan chat message when a clan war attack occurs. Send also the result.

• When we are on the global chat, show an alert for any new message in our clan chat.
• Allow leader & co to send as clan messages they want.
• Show a ratio of the 20 last won/lost wars to track the recent performances of a clan. Global history talks about former results (often with a former & forgotten team) which are irrelevants to understand how well a clan is today.

I dig the clan war deposit idea

I dig the best monthly donated ideal. Top three with most donates in the clan get a prize their elixir refilled and a trophy decoration to put on their base for the next month. Plus a indication on the clan list. For the next month.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lonewolf1234

I dig the best monthly donated ideal. Top three with most donates in the clan get a prize their elixir refilled and a trophy decoration to put on their base for the next month. Plus a indication on the clan list. For the next month.

---

Sorry but I don't agree, you should feel you want to donate troops because you want to help your clan mates and the clan itself improve, not because you can get free elixir out of it!!

As the top donater in my clan it would just be nice to have it indicated.so others could see and give all something to try for. To increase donations for the clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lonewolf1234

As the top donater in my clan it would just be nice to have it indicated.so others could see and give all something to try for. To increase donations for the clan.

---

Surely it's indicated by the number of donations you have beside your name in the clans list.
Players that want to help a clan and it's members will readily donate without something to " try for"

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rue73

Surely it's indicated by the number of donations you have beside your name in the clans list.
Players that want to help a clan and it's members will readily donate without something to " try for"

---

Something to "try for" only starts as a motive, once they've started donating, they'll continue regardless of whether they are winning the prize simply because it's nice to have a potential reward for good work or doing something right

EDIT: I love the clan challennges
I feel you need to expand on these new clan ranks, and what they do, what purpose they serve etc, as I can't really think of any on the too of my head
This sounds very GoW, MS inspired, the idea of clan loyalty, but I do think it would act as a nice small deterrent against hopping, spying etc etc the idea of loyalty and perhaps losing it all once you leave.
No, forcing members to donate a deposit for simply participating in a war, will see the people willing to wage war, rapidly decrease in number. I get that it's a deposit, but people make mistakes unintentionally, people have places to be and things to do, and it's their recourse, it shouldn't be taken away for something like that
Sure, more clan description space is always nice I guess
I like this idea, it could also be tied in with the loyalty.

Thats all for now ^^

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EpicChris

Something to "try for" only starts as a motive, once they've started donating, they'll continue regardless of whether they are winning the prize simply because it's nice to have a potential reward for good work or doing something right

---

I'm not sure that this is potentially the case, it could have the negative effect of players not bothering to donate because they know they won't get the prize.
It could also cause players to donate the cheapest and quickest to cook troops which again would cause a negative effect within the clan.

I run a clan where all members are expected to donate as much as they receive and use both attacks in war. Like most of the clan descriptions are saying. In war it can take hours for guys to donate troops . I do my best and others in the clan do also to cover as many of the requests. Those that do not donate do not get elder or Co and will get kicked. Just adding another achievement level on donations would help alot. Donate 50,000 100,000 and 250,000 troops get gold and relaxed or gems.

I added a 10th and a 11th new points.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CoralFrance

• New clan ranks.

---

What's wrong with the already existing ranks?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SuperCraftHeroes

What's wrong with the already existing ranks?

---

We could build a deeper clan organization.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CoralFrance

We could build a deeper clan organization.

---

Yes agree with that, the lack of clan ranking is very poor, would be good to have a couple of extra levels

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rue73

Sorry but I don't agree, you should feel you want to donate troops because you want to help your clan mates and the clan itself improve, not because you can get free elixir out of it!!

---

I agree with what you're saying but as someone who donates the most usually, and being the leader of the clan, it would be nice if their was a way of encouraging people to donate troops.. even if it was a subtle reward or something

I also think that there should be one rank below leader but is above Co,but just like the leader only one person can be that rank, so the leader must trust them. I thought of this idea because Wat if the leader wants to have a break.

pretty much agree.

I like most of these. The ones I don't like don't affect me.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rue73

Yes agree with that, the lack of clan ranking is very poor, would be good to have a couple of extra levels

---

Agreed!
In my perspective, there is a big difference in permissions between Elder and Co. So I suggest to add more ranks like Co-Elder (Who can only invite players) , or War beginner (Who can only start wars).

Rather than that, I prefer to add more buttons for Clan History, Co-Leaders' Chat, Donations Bank, Clan Rules, Recent Challenges, etc...

I hope that the next update includes something related to clans to be implemented :)

-Thanks