Costing gold to join a clan

I would like to suggest a few things. Some people tend to join clans only to receive troops and just leave which makes everyone upset, i suggest making it cost a certain amount of gold to join a clan, so that people think wisely about clan hopping. Costing gold will certainly outweigh the cost a receiving free troops. this will also make people in a clan more dedicated to donate and not only recieve troops so that they dont get kicked out of a clan.

i think making the cost system to joining a clan should be based on the town hall level. Maybe it should cost people with :
townhall 10 75000-100000 gold
townhall 9 60000-75000 gold
townhall 8 50000-60000 gold


all the way down to townhall 1 which should cost maybe 5000-10000 gold or maybe even free.

this is a one time fee to enter a clan. If you stay in the clan you pay nothing else. Just to be clear. Now if u want to move around, then you pay more and more. The purpose of this is to keep stability. .. Very simple


Please note, i dont suggest letting the gold paid to join a clan, go into the pockets of the clan members. Clan members dont take any of the gold

This would definately put a stop to hopping, but also if your loyal to a few clans, paying 100,000 gold just to be in all of them is WAY to much. How about how clans can set a trophie requirement, they could also set a gold requirement, from 0 to 50,000 gold. If they could choose how much gold it costs (if any) then that would be much better.it must be much harder to get people into your clan with requirements like that though, they would pick the cheapest clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Awes0meB0b

This would definately put a stop to hopping, but also if your loyal to a few clans, paying 100,000 gold just to be in all of them is WAY to much. How about how clans can set a trophie requirement, they could also set a gold requirement, from 0 to 50,000 gold. If they could choose how much gold it costs (if any) then that would be much better.it must be much harder to get people into your clan with requirements like that though, they would pick the cheapest clan

---

Just for your information, 100,000k is not much.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Catboy

Just for your information, 100,000k is not much.

---

Wie het kleine niet eert, is het grote niet weerd.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Catboy

Just for your information, 100,000k is not much.

---

Neither is 40,000, but people are always complaining about making their own clans

.... Rage face r u kidding me you want to stop hopper, but what bout your friend if they want to join your clan, how would that work, oh yea paying gold to join a clan, disagree, supercel plz rule this out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yoshispark7

.... Rage face r u kidding me you want to stop hopper, but what bout your friend if they want to join your clan, how would that work, oh yea paying gold to join a clan, disagree, supercel plz rule this out.

---

Son, again these are just suggested costs, and yess people would be willing to pay these amounts except the clan hoppers; And thats what were trying to eliminate. If my friend has no loyalty to be in my clan alone, thats his problem. Being in a clan is about sticking to one clan, and not going to 3 different clans. Its called "clash of clan"s, not "clash with three clans".

Paying gold will most certainly eliminate clan hoppers. And again, the higher the level of your town hall, the more you can afford the cost whether its 75k or 100k.. Thats up tobthe developers to decide the costs.

Seriously i need my gold, everyone need gold for upgrade, put a fee to join would be a disaster to low level player. My clan i help low lvl player, they dont deserve to pay fee, no one do, if it was add, people would delete coc, beg to remove the fee, and cause a internet riot. Supercell would be critize by players, hopper they stole 5 troop, seriously you care bout 5 troop, do u need 5 barbarian,archer, or goblin, you can just train them back. Clan fee is not gonna be put in coc forever, it a idea that destroy clash fanbase, for what 5 archer? This idea is dumb, ineffective, stupid, gamebreaker, low lvl destroyer, etc

A pay to go in clan is AMAZING!!!!! It will stop people from wasting their Resources hopping

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheRulingEmperor

A pay to go in clan is AMAZING!!!!! It will stop people from wasting their Resources hopping

---

U dont care bout low lvl player who just got a clan, paying a fee is like paying a tax.

I hate this idea, it a terrible terrible idea, need to be ruled out

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yoshispark7

I hate this idea, it a terrible terrible idea, need to be ruled out

---

Nope..its a great idea! Not only will it stop hoppers...it can benefit clan villages for future

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheRulingEmperor

Nope..its a great idea! Not only will it stop hoppers...it can benefit clan villages for future

---

Seriously i hate this idea, no one want to pay to join a clan, oh yea so eone stole 5 of your archer only 5 and youre %!$$ wow u got anger issue

I just started a poll on ths topic.

Ok 100,000 is a bit extreme, hoppers join LOTS OF CLANS, so why not just make it 10k, the troops you get from a clan will most likely be worth less than 10k.

If you say pay2join is good, u probably got troop stolen by hopper, it was your choice to donate you know.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yoshispark7

Seriously i need my gold, everyone need gold for upgrade, put a fee to join would be a disaster to low level player. My clan i help low lvl player, they dont deserve to pay fee, no one do, if it was add, people would delete coc, beg to remove the fee, and cause a internet riot. Supercell would be critize by players, hopper they stole 5 troop, seriously you care bout 5 troop, do u need 5 barbarian,archer, or goblin, you can just train them back. Clan fee is not gonna be put in coc forever, it a idea that destroy clash fanbase, for what 5 archer? This idea is dumb, ineffective, stupid, gamebreaker, low lvl destroyer, etc

---

If u need your gold then stop hopping around. And if anyone wants to keep their gold, let them stay in one clan. Thats the whole point of this suggestion; to limit people from jumper from one clan to another, unless they wanna pay a fee. If you choose to stay in the clan youre in then u dont pay anything else .. so simple . Now for people with lower levels will pay lower fees. This is not only about stealing 15-25 troops from one clan. Its about stability also. Everyone has been in a clan where u see green entrance and a red exit and green enterence font then red exit font.

And no need to be a drama queen .. people will not stop playong clash of clans of it costs them some gold to join one clan. Of they choose to stay in they dont pay anything ..

I agree that all the hopping should be stopped, but this suggestion is a bit out of the question IMO

Thats why there is an invite only option!

Instead of paying for joining, why not penalize someone for leaving 2 clans within a week period. This would drastically cut down on hopping. Would it eliminate it? No, but it would at least effectively hurt most.

Example 1: User joins Clan1. User takes troops and leaves Clan1. User joins Clan2. User takes troops and leaves Clan2.
Result 1: User is kept from joining any more clans until the 7 days has past from the time they left Clan1.

Example 2: User joins Clan1. Doesn't like it and leaves Clan1 without requesting troops. User joins Clan2 and leaves again while not taking any troops.
Result 2: No limit of clans that can be joined until troops are received.

Example 3: User joins Clan1. User takes troops and leaves Clan1. User joins Clan2. User doesn't take troops but leaves Clan2.
Result 3: No limit of clans that can be joined unless user joins another clan and receives troops within the same 7 day period.


Both examples the user should be able to donate troops.

This will allow main members to donate to feeder clans and rejoin their main clan with no penalization.

Thoughts?

I LOVE the idea it would stop hoppers but the prices are too high

Some high level players donate spam for XP. I'm pretty sure most of them would not like it.

Im dont like the idea of paying to join a clan, you already paid for your clan castle. BUT reversed, If you leave the clan within 3 days or something of being part of it, not kicked, like left, you could get fined, and it would go straight from the person to the clan members, also if they didnt have the cash it would limit them.

Not a big fan of this idea honestly.

No, just flat out no, hopping is not THAT big of a problem

U turned this into a poll wow

You copied my idea and turned into a poll, your are just made that people would rather spend gold on upgrade rather on fee on my poll.http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...to-join-a-clan

I was a co-leader in a clan once that had multiple feeders and I was to regularly move around among them to make sure everything was going smoothly. What happens then?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SirPsycho

I would like to suggest a few things. Some people tend to join clans only to receive troops and just leave which makes everyone upset, i suggest making it cost a certain amount of gold to join a clan, so that people think wisely about clan hopping. Costing gold will certainly outweigh the cost a receiving free troops. this will also make people in a clan more dedicated to donate and not only recieve troops so that they dont get kicked out of a clan.

i think making the cost system to joining a clan should be based on the town hall level. Maybe it should cost people with :
townhall 10 75000-100000 gold
townhall 9 60000-75000 gold
townhall 8 50000-60000 gold


all the way down to townhall 1 which should cost maybe 5000-10000 gold or maybe even free.


Please note, i dont suggest letting the gold paid to join a clan, go into the pockets of the clan members

---

so the gold goes to the people in the clan, that ruled out and dumb, it badically trading resource.

You know what a bigger problem than hopper troll who gpt elder, what if they kick ou would u want to pay a fee and get kick all over again.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yoshispark7

You know what a bigger problem than hopper troll who gpt elder, what if they kick ou would u want to pay a fee and get kick all over again.

---

If you get kicked, then thats because you were a bad member. It will encourage people to work harder in a clan. Son, you need to read the lines very well. Aso the money doesnt go to the pockets of the members, just like how when u attack u pay money. People would rather spend their money on resources, but were talking about a small fraction of what u earn when u attack someone. In one attack you could make double or even 10 times the cost of entering, based on the level of townhall ofcourse.


oh and next time you wanna use my idea in a poll that steers it negatively and bais. Think twice. .. Its all in the developers hands, not yours.

Thanks for charging me up to 200k to check my feeder. Classy.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AaronCZY

I was a co-leader in a clan once that had multiple feeders and I was to regularly move around among them to make sure everything was going smoothly. What happens then?

---

Im the leader of a clan with over 20000 trophies, we have a feeder clan also. These are some costs necessary to eliminate the high turn over rate, to promote stability and to eliminate hoppers. It will also make the game more competitive. People with higher townhall levels are most likely to pay more gold, if they want to move around; and yes they can afford it. Anyone can afford it. With one attack you can earn more than double the entrance fee.

Now if the developers introduce that sister clan option, your problems are solved.

ok lets see... what if people are jumping back and forth between feeder clans? that will eat up their gold.
prematures? very hard for them.
or simply just a person trying to find a good clan, but keeps on joining one, and doesn't like it, so leaves?

and TH1 and TH2, cant get a CC -.-

honestly, clan hopping is a problem that you just have to suck it up. since im in a small clan and stuff, you might be like "WELL YOU NEVER HAD A CLAN HOPPER SO YOU DON'T KNOW HOW IT'S LIKE, SO SHUT UP AND GO ♥♥♥♥ YOURSELF"

actually, i had gotten 1 clan hopper, about 3 months ago. i honestly didn't care. in fact, i got 2 or 3 of them. they request troops, we donate, they leave.

honestly, if they just join the clan and request troops, don't give them wizards or dragons, on the spot. give them some barbs and archers, so if they do leave, you'll just be like, "oh well they only took 5 lvl 5 archers, only 1000 elixir, who cares", rather than, "WHAT THE ♥♥♥♥ I HATE CLAN HOPPERS THEY TOOK MY LVL 4 DRAGON, 2 LVL 5 WIZARDS, AND 2 LVL 6 ARCHERS AND JUST RAN AWAY LIKE A LITTLE ♥♥♥♥♥Y COWARD THAT THEY ARE!"

we don't need to pay gold for joining a clan, there's many reasons for an innocent paying 100K gold, each time to find a good clan, but they're paying for not doing anything wrong. and joining 10 different clans? that a million gold! you can get a hidden tesla with that money! and there's always a non-money solution to deal with clan hoppers.

THOSE COSTS ARE RIDICULOUS!!!
To MAKE a clan its only 40k and now youre saying it costs 100k to JOIN one???

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Flamingsauce

THOSE COSTS ARE RIDICULOUS!!!
To MAKE a clan its only 40k and now youre saying it costs 100k to JOIN one???

---

Again, these are suggested cost. And the 100k your talking about is for people with level 10 town hall .. Oh the suggestion was somewhere between 75k-100k .. Which means it could be 75k .. Now for people with lower townhalls could join a clan for as low as 5k .. This is not only to eliminate hoppers, u guys need to understand what stability means. Stability means having a stable clan that doesnt have alot of turn over .. People can come for 3 days and leave, thats part of turn over .. It also encourages people to donate and be more active so that they dont get kicked out ...


Why are u guys only focusing on clan hoppers, its about clan stability and reduces the turn over rate..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yoshispark7

Seriously i need my gold, everyone need gold for upgrade, put a fee to join would be a disaster to low level player. My clan i help low lvl player, they dont deserve to pay fee, no one do, if it was add, people would delete coc, beg to remove the fee, and cause a internet riot. Supercell would be critize by players, hopper they stole 5 troop, seriously you care bout 5 troop, do u need 5 barbarian,archer, or goblin, you can just train them back. Clan fee is not gonna be put in coc forever, it a idea that destroy clash fanbase, for what 5 archer? This idea is dumb, ineffective, stupid, gamebreaker, low lvl destroyer, etc

---

If you're not a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ hopper this wouldn't really affect you. If you are in a clan, you would still be in it, free. Just joining a new clan would cost gold proportional to a TH level. Some hoppers take dragons and PEKKAs. How about this - to help your "low lvl clan members" out, one free join comes with the reconstruction of the Clan Castle. This is a very good idea. 100,000 gold is a single raid, and that would only be for TH10's! The point is this would help tremendously, and it isn't unfair. You have no reason not to be in favor of this unless you are a hopper yourself.

Just put a time limit on if you leave a clan you have to wait so many hours before you can join one again or gem the time that how most other games do it simple

1 massive problem it's the lower town halls that hopper normally 5,6 so they can request for dark troops

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Scrumpydog

Just put a time limit on if you leave a clan you have to wait so many hours before you can join one again or gem the time that how most other games do it simple

---

But then that stops you from changing clans. If you find a new clan why should you have to go clanless for a few hours in order to join it?

So to stop clan hoppers I rather wait couple hours then pay

Clan leader can set the price from ridiculously low to ridiculously high

great idea because i hate hoppers!

I rather not pay, too to much stuff that cost gold you know.

i don't know why you all bother about this so much
though i have to admit i don't know the problem myself, i'm in a clan with my RL-friends with invite only, but i would never give anything highernthan goblins to strangers, i also don't give anything higher than archer barbs goblins or maybe giants to a complete stranger

I love this idea and i hope supercell makes it reality

Two more before we can turn the tides!
Look people...how much the leader sets his price on his clan can tell how legit and cool and bad ♥♥♥ his clan is. If itus just some cheap clan...i woundt join it.. Would u buy a cheap chair that would break the next week? NO! So the more quality the clan gets, the more expensive it gets...also...quality hates sabotage....

for the cheap clans...the can set their price to 0 gold while everyone else who thinks their clan has some sort of a value....put a price tag on it.

Clan hopping is a problem, but what if I join a clan and all the players are rowdy and I simply don't like them? I would leave but it would be a waste of gold. Not a great idea... Because then I have to PAY to be with people I don't want to.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheRulingEmperor

Two more before we can turn the tides!
Look people...how much the leader sets his price on his clan can tell how legit and cool and bad ♥♥♥ his clan is. If itus just some cheap clan...i woundt join it.. Would u buy a cheap chair that would break the next week? NO! So the more quality the clan gets, the more expensive it gets...also...quality hates sabotage....

for the cheap clans...the can set their price to 0 gold while everyone else who thinks their clan has some sort of a value....put a price tag on it.

---

This is a really good idea, or maybe Supercell could come up with a formula that involves the member's Town Hall level, the total number of trophies and the average troops donated.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by teesee1

This is a really good idea, or maybe Supercell could come up with a formula that involves the member's Town Hall level, the total number of trophies and the average troops donated.

---

That is true and if we got clan associations there could be no fee to go in between those clans

Yes, I'm a very generous clan elder that donates tons of dragons and minions, I hate it when I lose a dragon to a hopper.

There is a same thread as this but the value of the clan is not only by its members....its how much their activities are..
Lu want an active clan..the fee might be worthwhile..by the way....the fee is not fixed...its going to be like the trophy requirements....you can even change it if you want to let a player get in for free...

I am part of a VERY loyal family of clans. In our clans, elders need to move between them. If this costed us gold, we would go broke. Leave it the way it is. Be more choosy about who you let in if you have a problem with hoppers. If someone take 5 troops from you, suck it up and make more.

This is a horrible idea

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Awes0meB0b

This would definately put a stop to hopping, but also if your loyal to a few clans, paying 100,000 gold just to be in all of them is WAY to much. How about how clans can set a trophie requirement, they could also set a gold requirement, from 0 to 50,000 gold. If they could choose how much gold it costs (if any) then that would be much better.it must be much harder to get people into your clan with requirements like that though, they would pick the cheapest clan

---

This would eliminate all of the good players from joining clans witch with hurt ever one in the long run so i NO!!!!!!!!

if implemented where will the gold go?

Either distribute it to the rest of the clan or have each clan have a setting of minimum stay required and if player stays for that minimum amount of time then return their entry cost if not then just pro-rate the cost. Kinda like an entry deposit that will be returned to you if you stay long enough....

I really like the idea a lot but i think its too expensive because it only costs 40,000 to create a clan. I think it should also be like a one time pay sort of thing so you pay once to enter a clan and if u leave you can join again without paying but the more clans you join the higher the price gets

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by eclogite

if implemented where will the gold go?

Either distribute it to the rest of the clan or have each clan have a setting of minimum stay required and if player stays for that minimum amount of time then return their entry cost if not then just pro-rate the cost. Kinda like an entry deposit that will be returned to you if you stay long enough....

---

That's a good idea!

How about..
• the price isn't fixed and can be controlled by the clan leader
• you must stay a certain amount of hours or days to not pay
• the money still goes to nowhere UNTIL the clan village has been fully implemented to the game where the money will rest to the clan village's coffers

This idea will only work if it scales up by town hall

why do you donate dragons to a person who just joined the clan? start out with minions first, that way if theyre a hopper, at least u only 50 DE at the most, and 3 mins 45 secs time.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheRulingEmperor

That's a good idea!

How about..
• the price isn't fixed and can be controlled by the clan leader
• you must stay a certain amount of hours or days to not pay
• the money still goes to nowhere UNTIL the clan village has been fully implemented to the game where the money will rest to the clan village's coffers

---

No. People should not be held hostage because they chose to join a clan where they are not a good fit.

I know you're in love with this idea, but it is not the way to stop hoppers. It creates more problems then it solves.

You want to fix hoppers? Create a leader configurable option that indicates how much time a person needs to spend in the clan before they can request.

I think the leader should set the amount to join the clan, and the money should be divided between members maybe just leaders and elders or maybe just to everyone

Instead of the set limit, we could have it so the leader decides the amount. Like someone said before, if you don't like the cost you could set the cost to zero. The cost would add prestige and would ultimately help stop hoppers. And to fix the problem of visiting feeders, I think that a new type of clan could be added called an empire. In the empire you could put all your clans in it and you only have to pay once (when first entering the empire) so you could join all your feeders for free.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CoCLoyalist

I am part of a VERY loyal family of clans. In our clans, elders need to move between them. If this costed us gold, we would go broke. Leave it the way it is. Be more choosy about who you let in if you have a problem with hoppers. If someone take 5 troops from you, suck it up and make more.

---

Yeah, just don't donate drags and pekkas to newbies and your problem is solved.

You need to change your question. Yes Clan hopping is a problem, but No I do not think paying to get in a clan as the solution. I'm part of a six clan clan family and move around the clans quite a bit.

We actually boot people that join the clan then immediately request troops. I think internal clan policy can handle the hoping issue. we don't have to create a law for everything. I'm a high level player and often join little clans to supply those new clans some much need troop relief. Everyone love maxed troops.

Derrick

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Awes0meB0b

This would definately put a stop to hopping, but also if your loyal to a few clans, paying 100,000 gold just to be in all of them is WAY to much. How about how clans can set a trophie requirement, they could also set a gold requirement, from 0 to 50,000 gold. If they could choose how much gold it costs (if any) then that would be much better.it must be much harder to get people into your clan with requirements like that though, they would pick the cheapest clan

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yoshispark7

Seriously i need my gold, everyone need gold for upgrade, put a fee to join would be a disaster to low level player. My clan i help low lvl player, they dont deserve to pay fee, no one do, if it was add, people would delete coc, beg to remove the fee, and cause a internet riot. Supercell would be critize by players, hopper they stole 5 troop, seriously you care bout 5 troop, do u need 5 barbarian,archer, or goblin, you can just train them back. Clan fee is not gonna be put in coc forever, it a idea that destroy clash fanbase, for what 5 archer? This idea is dumb, ineffective, stupid, gamebreaker, low lvl destroyer, etc

---

Yoshi, thats a good point but the idea is that the clan leader is able to choose the amount of gold required. If your clan doesnt like that idea, then your clan leader can simply put the amount of gold required to join at free. But then u have to consider the matter of hoppers, so u might want to put the gold requirement at a low lvl but still above zero.

(Ignore This) i accidently posted this twice so im editing it lol.

New Clan Members are not allowed to request until they donate.

A few simple ideas that would work to stop clan hoppers.

1: if you leave a clan you must wait X amount of days before joining a clan.

2: It costs X amount of gems to join a clan.

3: Clan admin/elders have ability to add user names to "Exile" list so hoppers can never rejoin.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kelemvour

A few simple ideas that would work to stop clan hoppers.

1: if you leave a clan you must wait X amount of days before joining a clan.

2: It costs X amount of gems to join a clan.

3: Clan admin/elders have ability to add user names to "Exile" list so hoppers can never rejoin.

---

1: as long as it not long

2: are you seriously paying gem!that dumb

3: Sorry blacklist is in the sticky, but not ruled out

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BUDDERPEGUIN43

Yoshi, thats a good point but the idea is that the clan leader is able to choose the amount of gold required. If your clan doesnt like that idea, then your clan leader can simply put the amount of gold required to join at free. But then u have to consider the matter of hoppers, so u might want to put the gold requirement at a low lvl but still above zero.

---

Where does the gold go? Nowhere
if it goes to member and leader, that trading resource and it ruled out, so it a lose lose for us and supercell

Really? Thats Alot for joining a clan What if you've started of a clan and you want people to join? would they join if it costs 40k? for one person!

Silly idea. Have you even thought about how much gold it would cost clans that have a family and people frequently go to other clans in the family to tell someone something.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rager

Silly idea. Have you even thought about how much gold it would cost clans that have a family and people frequently go to other clans in the family to tell someone something.

---

People who have sister clans or feeder clans can afford the premium. Now its not supposed to benefit everyone. But it does keep stability and it will eliminate people from jumping around. If the developers what to introduce a system where they can link sister clans together, then that should help ppl withsister clans. But this idea is for the greater good .. No one travels for free.

this idea isnt only about hoppers .. Its to encourage all members to be active, cause if theyre not, they will get kicked out. And will have to pay to find a new clan. And if theyre not active in the new clan, they will get kicked out aand again they will pay again for a new one. ...

People will be more active in all clans cause they dont want to get kicked out and pay again ... ( stability)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Catboy

Just for your information, 100,000k is not much.

---

100,000k is alot
100,000k=100,000,000

​i see the best wayto stop hoppers is that when someone leaves with recieved troops they simply dissappear... best idea and canthurt any family clans

Maybe you could refund the cost if the player donates troops inside the clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SirPsycho

People who have sister clans or feeder clans can afford the premium. Now its not supposed to benefit everyone. But it does keep stability and it will eliminate people from jumping around. If the developers what to introduce a system where they can link sister clans together, then that should help ppl withsister clans. But this idea is for the greater good .. No one travels for free.

this idea isnt only about hoppers .. Its to encourage all members to be active, cause if theyre not, they will get kicked out. And will have to pay to find a new clan. And if theyre not active in the new clan, they will get kicked out aand again they will pay again for a new one. ...

People will be more active in all clans cause they dont want to get kicked out and pay again ... ( stability)

---

I don't think you realize what you're suggesting. You say a town hall 9, which I am, would have to pay 75k gold. Well, if I wanted to switch between all of the clans I am a part of in a short period of time, that adds up to 225k gold. Just to switch clans. Think about that. The invite only setting is there for a reason. If you need stability, then use it. I will not be paying 225k gold to visit my clanmates, even if I can afford it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SirPsycho

People will be more active in all clans cause they dont want to get kicked out and pay again ... ( stability)

---

Au contraire sir. This will keep clan members in constant fear, a fear of being eliminated from their clan and having to find a new one. And I guarantee you, there will be clans which make people pay the fee, only to kick the person right afterwards, just for laughs. I don't think you fully comprehend the consequences of this idea, and you need to step back and look at it from a wider perspective. You consider yourself to be suggesting for the greater good of CoC, yet this feature will only benefit the new up and coming clans, and will greatly hurt the already established families.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MoHandles

Au contraire sir. This will keep clan members in constant fear, a fear of being eliminated from their clan and having to find a new one. And I guarantee you, there will be clans which make people pay the fee, only to kick the person right afterwards, just for laughs. I don't think you fully comprehend the consequences of this idea, and you need to step back and look at it from a wider perspective. You consider yourself to be suggesting for the greater good of CoC, yet this feature will only benefit the new up and coming clans, and will greatly hurt the already established families.

---

I like it. DOWN WITH THE ESTABLISHMENT! ON WITH THE NEW AND RADICAL!!!!

nah..it will benefit both new and old clans

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheRulingEmperor

I like it. DOWN WITH THE ESTABLISHMENT! ON WITH THE NEW AND RADICAL!!!!

nah..it will benefit both new and old clans

---

How so? The old clans don't get hoppers, because they already have their members and are on invite only, thus preventing the hoppers from getting in. Furthermore, the older clans usually have feeders or sister clans they like to visit, costing them precious gold.

its mostly low lvl players who have not much money so its a great idea i like it :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MoHandles

How so? The old clans don't get hoppers, because they already have their members and are on invite only, thus preventing the hoppers from getting in. Furthermore, the older clans usually have feeders or sister clans they like to visit, costing them precious gold.

---

We could combine my idea and this idea (My idea being something which can connect the feeder clan to the main clan, check the thread for more) and make it so you don't have to pay money to move to the feeder.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MoHandles

How so? The old clans don't get hoppers, because they already have their members and are on invite only, thus preventing the hoppers from getting in. Furthermore, the older clans usually have feeders or sister clans they like to visit, costing them precious gold.

---

Im part of the elite army and i like to visit it, so putting pay2join is a terrible idea for people who have feeder, second clan, and a friend they want to visit.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MoHandles

Au contraire sir. This will keep clan members in constant fear, a fear of being eliminated from their clan and having to find a new one. And I guarantee you, there will be clans which make people pay the fee, only to kick the person right afterwards, just for laughs. I don't think you fully comprehend the consequences of this idea, and you need to step back and look at it from a wider perspective. You consider yourself to be suggesting for the greater good of CoC, yet this feature will only benefit the new up and coming clans, and will greatly hurt the already established families.

---

Troll these day ruining every game especial cod and coc

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Awes0meB0b

This would definately put a stop to hopping, but also if your loyal to a few clans, paying 100,000 gold just to be in all of them is WAY to much. How about how clans can set a trophie requirement, they could also set a gold requirement, from 0 to 50,000 gold. If they could choose how much gold it costs (if any) then that would be much better.it must be much harder to get people into your clan with requirements like that though, they would pick the cheapest clan

---

100.000k is like...uhmmm...nothing,and i belive that a person should be loyal to one clan.The word 'loyal' is a powetful word.

I've already posted a thread with this, but I'll say it again: Required donation before requesting.

My poll is better, this poll is a thread that change to a poll cuz i started a poll and everyone said no, now sirpsycho is trying to copy my idea and make it a poll, such a copycat.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yoshispark7

My poll is better, this poll is a thread that change to a poll cuz i started a poll and everyone said no, now sirpsycho is trying to copy my idea and make it a poll, such a copycat.

---

Son ♥♥♥♥ .. You copied my thread and poll .. .. And my amazing idea ...


Look at which got posted first

I think the gold needs to go SOMEWHERE, otherwise loot will start to be deflated out of the game.

Ehmm, I think
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-options%21%29
is a better solution, read idea number two.

JOIN OUR CLAN JOIN OUR CLAN BUT FOR A LOW PRICE!

You came in that clan...you found out its a horrible clan..boohoo...you wasted you gold for
1.not checking the price being advertize
2.not checking the clan..


now i see an advantage to that...
1. Clanless players will be more attentive on joining clans
2. We will know more of our clan mates if they decided to stay
3. Gold price will define whether you clan is worth it or not.



for you naysayers out there....you can't never think past your loot....that's greediness......Thik past it and look how will it contribute to other clans.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheRulingEmperor

JOIN OUR CLAN JOIN OUR CLAN BUT FOR A LOW PRICE!

You came in that clan...you found out its a horrible clan..boohoo...you wasted you gold for
1.not checking the price being advertize
2.not checking the clan..


now i see an advantage to that...
1. Clanless players will be more attentive on joining clans
2. We will know more of our clan mates if they decided to stay
3. Gold price will define whether you clan is worth it or not.



for you naysayers out there....you can't never think past your loot....that's greediness......Thik past it and look how will it contribute to other clans.

---

nw let see the disadvantage
1: Donator get mad
2: Troll who got elder
3: 1 man clan get made
4: Where do the gold go, it cant go to member or that resource trading(ruled out)
5: Most people dont want it.
6: You just build a clan castle now you have yo pay again
7: Too many thing cost alot of gold
8: We already have a attack fee
9: Everyone like Free2Join clan
10: It useless and people wont play clash if it put in the game
There a lot of cons

1: Donator get mad
..donators are in the clan....what's the point of leaving..BTW its one time pay only
2: Troll who got elder
You still make rules! Too bad if they got kicked out...happened to me one too many times but i don't care
3: 1 man clan get mad
..then those people are lazy.....people will join clans..
4: Where do the gold go, it cant go to member or that resource trading(ruled out)
gold will just disappear....or when Clan village is introduced..goes to the storages of Clan Village
5: Most people dont want it. well...suck it up......some people like it...your poll is actually losing..Meh means i dont care so combine with yes...more powerful than horrible
6: You just build a clan castle now you have yo pay again
there are free clan clans to join because ITS NOT FIXED PRICE!
7: Too many thing cost alot of gold
i know that but it will still benefit CoC
8: We already have a attack fee
i dont care
9: Everyone like Free2Join clan
Again..there will be clans that are free to enter but quality is better than quantity...
10: It useless and people wont play clash if it put in the game.
We have updates that destroy and rebuild the game......it's just balance...for u, destroyed..for some..stability..
There a lot of cons
..and I will make a lot of pros

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheRulingEmperor

1: Donator get mad
..donators are in the clan....what's the point of leaving..BTW its one time pay only
2: Troll who got elder
You still make rules! Too bad if they got kicked out...happened to me one too many times but i don't care
3: 1 man clan get mad
..then those people are lazy.....people will join clans..
4: Where do the gold go, it cant go to member or that resource trading(ruled out)
gold will just disappear....or when Clan village is introduced..goes to the storages of Clan Village
5: Most people dont want it. well...suck it up......some people like it...your poll is actually losing..Meh means i dont care so combine with yes...more powerful than horrible
6: You just build a clan castle now you have yo pay again
there are free clan clans to join because ITS NOT FIXED PRICE!
7: Too many thing cost alot of gold
i know that but it will still benefit CoC
8: We already have a attack fee
i dont care
9: Everyone like Free2Join clan
Again..there will be clans that are free to enter but quality is better than quantity...
10: It useless and people wont play clash if it put in the game.
We have updates that destroy and rebuild the game......it's just balance...for u, destroyed..for some..stability..
There a lot of cons
..and I will make a lot of pros

---

Seriously how is hopper a problem, they took your 5 archer and your mad, u got anger issue, there are differnet type of hopper good and bad, if you damage the bad, it also effect the good, people who donate and leave will get very ver very very very mad

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SirPsycho

Son ♥♥♥♥ .. You copied my thread and poll .. .. And my amazing idea ...


Look at which got posted first

---

I only started a poll to reliate, the no are winning in my poll

stop it with this terrible idea. this should never be added, as it will just make people angry. just deal with hoppers, no one is asking you to donate dragons right to the people when they join, just donate barbs for a startout

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pranav

stop it with this terrible idea. this should never be added, as it will just make people angry. just deal with hoppers, no one is asking you to donate dragons right to the people when they join, just donate barbs for a startout

---

Dude plz dont talk when you dont want to talk, it annoying

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pranav

stop it with this terrible idea. this should never be added, as it will just make people angry. just deal with hoppers, no one is asking you to donate dragons right to the people when they join, just donate barbs for a startout

---

Why dis you make your word white, people cant barely see it. Stop doing it plz.

Town hall 10 loot is horrible anyways, now this? All TH10s would quit on the spot.