Costing gold to join a clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yoshispark7

You know what a bigger problem than hopper troll who gpt elder, what if they kick ou would u want to pay a fee and get kick all over again.

---

If you get kicked, then thats because you were a bad member. It will encourage people to work harder in a clan. Son, you need to read the lines very well. Aso the money doesnt go to the pockets of the members, just like how when u attack u pay money. People would rather spend their money on resources, but were talking about a small fraction of what u earn when u attack someone. In one attack you could make double or even 10 times the cost of entering, based on the level of townhall ofcourse.


oh and next time you wanna use my idea in a poll that steers it negatively and bais. Think twice. .. Its all in the developers hands, not yours.

Thanks for charging me up to 200k to check my feeder. Classy.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AaronCZY

I was a co-leader in a clan once that had multiple feeders and I was to regularly move around among them to make sure everything was going smoothly. What happens then?

---

Im the leader of a clan with over 20000 trophies, we have a feeder clan also. These are some costs necessary to eliminate the high turn over rate, to promote stability and to eliminate hoppers. It will also make the game more competitive. People with higher townhall levels are most likely to pay more gold, if they want to move around; and yes they can afford it. Anyone can afford it. With one attack you can earn more than double the entrance fee.

Now if the developers introduce that sister clan option, your problems are solved.

ok lets see... what if people are jumping back and forth between feeder clans? that will eat up their gold.
prematures? very hard for them.
or simply just a person trying to find a good clan, but keeps on joining one, and doesn't like it, so leaves?

and TH1 and TH2, cant get a CC -.-

honestly, clan hopping is a problem that you just have to suck it up. since im in a small clan and stuff, you might be like "WELL YOU NEVER HAD A CLAN HOPPER SO YOU DON'T KNOW HOW IT'S LIKE, SO SHUT UP AND GO ♥♥♥♥ YOURSELF"

actually, i had gotten 1 clan hopper, about 3 months ago. i honestly didn't care. in fact, i got 2 or 3 of them. they request troops, we donate, they leave.

honestly, if they just join the clan and request troops, don't give them wizards or dragons, on the spot. give them some barbs and archers, so if they do leave, you'll just be like, "oh well they only took 5 lvl 5 archers, only 1000 elixir, who cares", rather than, "WHAT THE ♥♥♥♥ I HATE CLAN HOPPERS THEY TOOK MY LVL 4 DRAGON, 2 LVL 5 WIZARDS, AND 2 LVL 6 ARCHERS AND JUST RAN AWAY LIKE A LITTLE ♥♥♥♥♥Y COWARD THAT THEY ARE!"

we don't need to pay gold for joining a clan, there's many reasons for an innocent paying 100K gold, each time to find a good clan, but they're paying for not doing anything wrong. and joining 10 different clans? that a million gold! you can get a hidden tesla with that money! and there's always a non-money solution to deal with clan hoppers.

THOSE COSTS ARE RIDICULOUS!!!
To MAKE a clan its only 40k and now youre saying it costs 100k to JOIN one???

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Flamingsauce

THOSE COSTS ARE RIDICULOUS!!!
To MAKE a clan its only 40k and now youre saying it costs 100k to JOIN one???

---

Again, these are suggested cost. And the 100k your talking about is for people with level 10 town hall .. Oh the suggestion was somewhere between 75k-100k .. Which means it could be 75k .. Now for people with lower townhalls could join a clan for as low as 5k .. This is not only to eliminate hoppers, u guys need to understand what stability means. Stability means having a stable clan that doesnt have alot of turn over .. People can come for 3 days and leave, thats part of turn over .. It also encourages people to donate and be more active so that they dont get kicked out ...


Why are u guys only focusing on clan hoppers, its about clan stability and reduces the turn over rate..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by yoshispark7

Seriously i need my gold, everyone need gold for upgrade, put a fee to join would be a disaster to low level player. My clan i help low lvl player, they dont deserve to pay fee, no one do, if it was add, people would delete coc, beg to remove the fee, and cause a internet riot. Supercell would be critize by players, hopper they stole 5 troop, seriously you care bout 5 troop, do u need 5 barbarian,archer, or goblin, you can just train them back. Clan fee is not gonna be put in coc forever, it a idea that destroy clash fanbase, for what 5 archer? This idea is dumb, ineffective, stupid, gamebreaker, low lvl destroyer, etc

---

If you're not a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ hopper this wouldn't really affect you. If you are in a clan, you would still be in it, free. Just joining a new clan would cost gold proportional to a TH level. Some hoppers take dragons and PEKKAs. How about this - to help your "low lvl clan members" out, one free join comes with the reconstruction of the Clan Castle. This is a very good idea. 100,000 gold is a single raid, and that would only be for TH10's! The point is this would help tremendously, and it isn't unfair. You have no reason not to be in favor of this unless you are a hopper yourself.

Just put a time limit on if you leave a clan you have to wait so many hours before you can join one again or gem the time that how most other games do it simple

1 massive problem it's the lower town halls that hopper normally 5,6 so they can request for dark troops

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Scrumpydog

Just put a time limit on if you leave a clan you have to wait so many hours before you can join one again or gem the time that how most other games do it simple

---

But then that stops you from changing clans. If you find a new clan why should you have to go clanless for a few hours in order to join it?