Printable View
OK so I had this genius idea and it's when you start a clan war you should be able to select an "alternate". For instance we had this dude leave, for good, right before war started. So I believe a Co-leader or the leader should be able to swap out the ex-clan member and pull up the war alternate. This should only be able to happen during preparation day. Would love your thoughts and feedback!
Yeah that's a pretty good idea.
For 20v20, you could select your initial 20 then select for instance 2 people that are on 'Standby' in case up to 2 people leave, essentially selecting 22 people but only two being backups.
It'd certainly reduce the risk of sometimes putting new people in war, potentially giving other people the chance if they do leave.
Exactly my friendQuote:
Originally Posted by joecompt9
Only thing is that if somebody weak drops out and there's somebody strong on standby, it could make the war unfair. It'd have to be balanced somehow and I'm not sure how it could work
Good point, maybe the alternate can only be as high a town hall as the middle person in war?Quote:
Originally Posted by joecompt9
Yeah that'd work, even having somebody a lower level will be better than having nobody at all so it'd still be effective.
Just hope others view this and give feedback and ideas, not just us two.
Yeah lol it'd certainly help!
Just gonna get this back to the top of the page for hopefully some more views
I don't think it's a good idea the way it's written. Like it was stated, it can be abused. Swapping a TH9 for a TH9 is not going to be an equal trade because you can have a rushed TH9 leave and replace him with an almost maxed TH9. The difference between rushed, new, and maxed TH9 is big and it only gets bigger at TH10 and TH11. It would almost certainly be abused by the clans that try to scam their way to wins.
OK so there is one thing in a war, that determines the loot you get from a raid. It's what they use to evenly match clans. So maybe the alternate has to have an equal/lower level thing. (IDK what it is called, but the loot you get for raiding the base (not war bonus)). Do you have any suggestions?Quote:
Originally Posted by Morober
If this did happen, then that replacement would have to be like a th3, because any other th level could be abused. This is also fairly unlikely to happen, due to the fact that it is nearly impossible to find an identical or nearly identical replacement for someone.