Three QOL Features I'd Like to See Added in Clash

Would love some feedback on a few minor quality of life additions I'd like to see added to the game. I'd like to suggest these to SC but would first like to see if my ideas could be tweaked or improved on based on your opinions.

1) Member Online Count - Similar to Clash Royale, you'd be able to see how many of your clanmates were online at any given time. Being the leader of an alliance of clans that are all international this would provide us with some useful data for recruitment to help bolster our activity in certain time zones. Also, it will be useful to see how many people are online when issuing friendly challenge and setting up tornaments and contests.

2) Copy Base Feature - I personality think it's time to allow folks to also be able to copy bases into one of their six saved base slots. I can see the counter argument that base building lends itself to improvisation and some may actually enjoy making bases. I do respect that but with friendly challenge I find that I just want to attack, all the time! I like the idea of tweaking bases and designing them from scratch, too. I don't think a copy base feature would get in the way of those activities, especially for folks who are more limited in time.

3) Saved defensive troops for FC clan castles - I'd like to see a separate area that allows you to set your defensive clan castle troops for friendly challenge. I don't think it would hurt or effect the economy if these troops were also free of charge. Right now it's a real pain when you're using mainly Golems for offensive clan castles and have to switch it to minions/hound/drag for a proper defense in friendly challenge mode. I think a separate clan castle is in order.

Thoughts?

Agree with all 3

Hasn't Supercell already crossed out idea number? Great ideas BTW.

Edit: I mean number 1.

It's just nice to have I think. Without I would still play, but I agree that they would be nice.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Boom57

Hasn't Supercell already crossed out idea number? Great ideas BTW.

Edit: I mean number 1.

---

Supercell crossed out Friendly Challenge, then added it to the game.

Answers to each of your ideas:

1) This idea is unfortunately ruled out by the Clash team for the time being.
2) I don't like this idea, because since I am a good base designer, my TH9 war base usually ends up being one of the only ones not 3-starred in war. I don't want the enemy clan to be able to copy my hard-worked-on base with a single click. This is also a problem because if the enemy clan members start using the base, then the base will spread and soon it may become a popular "internet" base that everyone knows how to 3-star.
3) This idea makes sense and I have no objections.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BBaBy

Supercell crossed out Friendly Challenge, then added it to the game.

---

Friendly Challenges were never ruled out. In fact, the number 1 most requested feature pre-update according to the sticky in Ideas & Feature Requests subforum was a battle area where people could "sandbox" bases.

Cool ideas ash!

I'd love to have my heroes available for friendly challenge will upgrading. Not war, just challenge. I sometimes gem them for war, but it's not worth it for FC. It should just be added, I mean, they are available on defense in FC while upgrading...

Also, you wouldn't be able to copy traps and teslas when you copy base, this seems obvious, but you didn't mention it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jlam2

2) I don't like this idea, because since I am a good base designer, my TH9 war base usually ends up being one of the only ones not 3-starred in war. I don't want the enemy clan to be able to copy my hard-worked-on base with a single click. This is also a problem because if the enemy clan members start using the base, then the base will spread and soon it may become a popular "internet" base that everyone knows how to 3-star.

---

Great point jlam2. Didn't think of this before you said it. Not that I have an awesome war base haha.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ashlain

Would love some feedback on a few minor quality of life additions I'd like to see added to the game. I'd like to suggest these to SC but would first like to see if my ideas could be tweaked or improved on based on your opinions.

1) Member Online Count - Similar to Clash Royale, you'd be able to see how many of your clanmates were online at any given time. Being the leader of an alliance of clans that are all international this would provide us with some useful data for recruitment to help bolster our activity in certain time zones. Also, it will be useful to see how many people are online when issuing friendly challenge and setting up tornaments and contests.

2) Copy Base Feature - I personality think it's time to allow folks to also be able to copy bases into one of their six saved base slots. I can see the counter argument that base building lends itself to improvisation and some may actually enjoy making bases. I do respect that but with friendly challenge I find that I just want to attack, all the time! I like the idea of tweaking bases and designing them from scratch, too. I don't think a copy base feature would get in the way of those activities, especially for folks who are more limited in time.

3) Saved defensive troops for FC clan castles - I'd like to see a separate area that allows you to set your defensive clan castle troops for friendly challenge. I don't think it would hurt or effect the economy if these troops were also free of charge. Right now it's a real pain when you're using mainly Golems for offensive clan castles and have to switch it to minions/hound/drag for a proper defense in friendly challenge mode. I think a separate clan castle is in order.

Thoughts?

---

1). Are you managing or leading? There are many that do not want this feature and don't want to be "managed"...it's a game, not a job. I believe it has already been ruled out as well.

2). Why, because people are not creative enough to design there own base or because they are too lazy to do so. Terrible idea for war clans as well.

3). This one I can agree with.