Use the same donating system from "Clash Royale" and that would completely stuff up all these useless players just hopping and donating bloody giants, hunting for the "Friend in need" achievement! Should be an easy fix supercell, c'mon.
Printable View
Use the same donating system from "Clash Royale" and that would completely stuff up all these useless players just hopping and donating bloody giants, hunting for the "Friend in need" achievement! Should be an easy fix supercell, c'mon.
I'm not sure what you're referring to. Maybe you could elaborate.
Would ruin REQ n LEAVE clans.
When I open my clan up to anyone, instead of invite only, most of the people coming in are just hopping from clan to clan donating giants, no matter what is being requested. If we were to make requests like in "Clash Royale", where you request a particular troop with a button, then the people donating can ONLY donate that troop.
If you know that most entering your clan are hoppers when you set it anyone can join, then why do it? Seems like common sense to keep at invite only if you consistently have issues with this.Quote:
Originally Posted by Royzhaus
You have the tools to solve your issue, use them.
Invite only is a massive deterrent for new people, need to keep the numbers up, might get 2 good member from every 100, I sort through. Dude, I don't have time advertising my clan anymore... And most of the ♥♥♥♥ are noobs from the middle east...
I like your idea but have to explain deeply that for how much time is donation limited for. If you it's limited for 24×7 then it's worst idea. Explain more.
I agree with OP. There should be maybe a set of buttons with pictures of troops, that you can select to request. Anyone trying to donate what is not preset in the request, shouldn't be able to
If a clanmate repeatedly donates wrong troop kick them not a team player and of no use to clan problem solved.
You're obviously not a clan leader that has to deal with keeping the numbers up, so we can have wars larger than 10vs10. Obviously I kick them out, but having this system, would remove hoppers altogether, or at least a huge group of them. Make the donations the same waiting period, 10 minutes in my case. Everything the same, just using cards, like in "Clash Royale".
Not everyone donates giants(only the lazy people or the rich people)
You'd be very surprised, I'd say 80% of the people that join my clan either donate giants and hop away, or just request troops (without donating) before I kick them out (after about 150 troops recieved) . Thanks for your enlightening input, though!
I am sure that once in a lifetime you also donated those giants, minions and barbarians in REQ N' ♥♥♥♥ clans!Quote:
Originally Posted by Royzhaus
You place troops in the bank and anyone can take them out (24 hours after joining to discourage hoppers) and then u can ask in the chat but u can't get wrong donation
Yeah, that idea would be pretty cool. ANYTHING to deter those bloody hopping giant Donators !