Printable View
Can we get it set so is someone is in a war and they leave the clan they can not join again and be able to use the war attacks. The war we are in now I have watched every member of the clan leave and return to do war attacks with maxed cc troops that even with the upgraded donations they did not get from thier clan, and it showed them not in their clan before they made their attacks.
Well, this would be the end of clan hoppers warring. And clans with sister clans. Plus a lot of other stuff.
I strongly disagree with this request. If you have the means to get higher level troops from another clan and they're willing to give them to you, then I think you'd be working the right strategy by taking advantage of that. Considering it a bad thing makes no sense.
It is frustrating when you see a player leave during a war and return later to fight, however CC troops do not make the war it's the player behind them.
I personally think it would be good if players couldn't hop in and out of a war, more for the fact that it encourages the very thing we all complain about, hoppers!!!
if they were kicked from the clan they cannot rejoin for at least 24 hours. too bad it doesn't apply to those who leave on their ownsome
Not all hoppers are bad. It's such an ambiguous term in my opinion. There are hoppers that consistently join clans and leave soon after. There are hoppers that join clans to spam them or be greedy (only request troops, never donate, and are useless in war are examples). There are people who have sister clans that hop between the two (or however many) to help out friends. Of all these hoppers, obviously hoppers between sister clans are the least annoying in my opinion. They shouldn't even be considered a bad thing to be honest. What's so bad about being in a war in one clan, hopping to another (say for troops) and coming back to attack in war??? It harms no one. Especially if they are actually coming back. Sure, hoppers with bad intentions shouldn't be allowed to do what they do but taking action against their actions would prohibit people from easily playing with more of their friends on clash (again, sister clan reference). I hop between two clans, one is a feeder to a larger more serious clan and for the most part we all know each other. The larger clan has 42/50 members. The smaller one has 18. Obviously we can't all be in the same clan so we have to hop back and forth when necessary to play with our other friends. So tell me, what is so wrong with that?
Bro...you can also hop to other clan nd take max troops. .rules are same to every player. Opponent is having privilage to get max troop nd u don't ..why you jealous
Only hoppers wouldn't want a rule banning anyone from hopping, it's ungamemanship, it's cheating & it annoying that people feel the need to hop between clans to get troops, that's the whole part of being in a clan, is that you help each other, hoppers just drop in, ask for troops, which good clan members happily hand over from their own hard earn troops, then they vanish without a word.... I personally have handed out hundreds/thousands of troops to hoppers, so have others in my clan for nothing in reply, I fight hard to earn gold/elixir, so how is it fair for hoppers to just drop in & ask for troops & give me nothing in return?? My biggest gripe is against anyone who joins, isn't RED but then leaves after you've selected them for war.... that really, really rips the proverbial out of me, those type of hoppers need banning for longer or anyone who is picked for war shouldn't be allowed to hop until said war is finished, as it makes it an unfair advantage to you opponents!!
Then don't give troops to people who have yet to prove their loyalty to your clan. You honestly paid no attention to the point I made if you're saying this in response to me. I don't hop between clan to "take troops and give nothing in return." Maybe some people do that, but you can't punish everyone for only certain people's actions.
Also, if you're matched up against a clan in war you shouldn't have to care what donated troops they're using against you. Matchmaking is balanced enough so it shouldn't be too difficult to win wars if you have the actual skill needed to do so.