Are Challenges Going To Be Boring?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SpeakerForTheDead

How would it be exploited?

---

Multiple ways, but here's one example, right off the top of my head.

Say you have a clan of 30 members, go to war with anything less than that. Form a new clan and strategically not include certain members in the current war to join this other clan. This is especially easy if people have alts, which seems very, very common nowadays (hell, we have several in my clan right now).

Well, fill in the blanks after that.

The bottom line is that many will go to great lengths to gain an edge--this is a proven fact---and here is no exception.

I, for one, don't even want to worry about whether an attack was pure or an advantage was gained through practice.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lunaticfringe

Multiple ways, but here's one example, right off the top of my head.

Say you have a clan of 30 members, go to war with anything less than that. Form a new clan and strategically not include certain members in the current war to join this other clan. This is especially easy if people have alts, which seems very, very common nowadays (hell, we have several in my clan right now).

Well, fill in the blanks after that.

The bottom line is that many will go to great lengths to gain an edge--this is a proven fact---and here is no exception.

I, for one, don't even want to worry about whether an attack was pure or an advantage was gained through practice.

---

I don't see this being an issue.

For your idea to work, you would need a minimum of ten accounts, all ten people/accounts must be willing to construct new bases during prep day, the war must be over before the main clans war is over. You would need time to practice enough to win a base and then teach it to other clanmates or have another account with comparable troops.

Teaching someone else how to do it is not as effective, so the only other way your idea would really work is if each of the ten people have two accounts of equivalent th and troops levels.

Furthermore, all traps and teslas will be inaccurate because the main clan can't see them all. So the secondary clan is guessing how to build bases since their war must be over before the main clans war is over.

I think the logistics are too much, and nearly impossible to replicate the opponents bases and your own teams troops.

No, it's not and I'm not the only person who has said this.

As stated many times, it's really only at the top where you need to focus your attention most the time anyways. Further, you don't have to have 10 people doing that anyways. It's likely very easy to exploit, in many situations.

Besides, the timer restriction is a much, much better idea. THAT is very, very difficult to get around.

Simple... stop showing opponents bases on prep day... if we are to use this feature it cant be allowed to be used in a clan or by people present when war is declared. Everyone knows people will practice on similar bases a bunch of times before attacking for real. Obviously this is a load of b.s.

For that to work for 24/7 warring clans to use the feature ever then opponents bases cant be viewable on prep day. Frankly prep day needs re worked entirely... I see no reason for prep day longer then 4 hours. Troops should be loaded from a bank of troops automatically taken if the troops are present. Guilds just load up on the troops used to fill ccs.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lunaticfringe

No, it's not and I'm not the only person who has said this.

As stated many times, it's really only at the top where you need to focus your attention most the time anyways. Further, you don't have to have 10 people doing that anyways. It's likely very easy to exploit, in many situations.

Besides, the timer restriction is a much, much better idea. THAT is very, very difficult to get around.

---

You need at least ten people to start a war. Even if you only do the top three bases, you would still have to time the war so that second clan ends before first clan, guess where traps are since u won't know for sure, and have comparable troops and defenses for each of the bases. I don't see the exploit, just a lot of guesswork and tedious planning/timing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jcman

Simple... stop showing opponents bases on prep day... if we are to use this feature it cant be allowed to be used in a clan or by people present when war is declared. Everyone knows people will practice on similar bases a bunch of times before attacking for real. Obviously this is a load of b.s.

For that to work for 24/7 warring clans to use the feature ever then opponents bases cant be viewable on prep day. Frankly prep day needs re worked entirely... I see no reason for prep day longer then 4 hours. Troops should be loaded from a bank of troops automatically taken if the troops are present. Guilds just load up on the troops used to fill ccs.

---

I agree, a shortened prep day would solve the issue for 24/7 war clans.

This is the solution. and imo the only solution (that wont ♥♥♥♥ of people)

Make it so that as soon as someone clicks "remove all" in a base design, that layout cannot be practiced on for 48 hours.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SpeakerForTheDead

The feature is only available AFTER war is over, and it goes away once the next war is found.

---

Dont want to burst your bubble ... Join alternate clan... Practice how much you want with copied base.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cyberus

Dont want to burst your bubble ... Join alternate clan... Practice how much you want with copied base.

---

Did you read the post?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SpeakerForTheDead

Did you read the post?

---

itss till a terrible idea haha. will make quite a few clans mad

Make it so that as soon as someone clicks "remove all" in a base design, that layout cannot be practiced on for 48 hours.