Just that ⬆️.....
Printable View
Just that ⬆️.....
I've been playing for over 2 years, and have never been in global... Join a clan, problem solved!
Just mute them, that way you wont see them.
Please give the minority their own global since the majorities are obviously Indians.
Who is gonna make them go there, or stay there for that matter?
^this.Quote:
Originally Posted by Carmelina
Embrace multiculturalism, OP.
There would perhaps be a new language to select from in the options menu. So rather than picking english, they would select "indian" or "south asian" etc, which would be separate to the english server.Quote:
Originally Posted by KarmicJustice
Wouldn't that negate the term "global". Think it over for a minute.
India has over 20 different languages. That reflects your ignorance.Quote:
Originally Posted by Namess
Separate but equal also goes against the point of a global. But hey, Jim Crowe laws and Aparthied were both undone in the last 60 years, so these suggestions won't get any serious consideration
There's currently 15 languages, english, french, spanish, italian, norsk, turkish, chinese and arabic, to name a few. You dont see them in global as they have their own one.Quote:
Originally Posted by Guscleatus
Yet you can use your 20+ languages perfectly fine in the english global? Dont think people would complain if everyone in english used english.Quote:
Originally Posted by KarmicJustice
Oh come on man, get off your high horse, it was an innocent suggestion to try and make it easier not just for the English speakers but also the Indians, no stereotyping and definitely no racism.Quote:
Originally Posted by KarmicJustice
I'm not Indian, buckaroo.Quote:
Originally Posted by Namess
Game sorts globals by supported languages, not regions. French global has nearly every african country in it. English global includes Britian, The US, Canada, New Zealand, and Australia.
If you wanted to have a fair global, you'd have to either support 20 more languages added to global, or only offer Hindi, which more than 30% of India doesn't even speak. Suprisingly, English is the second or third language used by most people in that country, and is considered one of the primary languages in that country.
That or force every country into their own "national" chat, because it sure as ♥♥♥♥ ain't a global otherwise.
But hey, tell me all about how Norsk feels about all them english speakers in their global?
I'm sure making an "Indian Global" will totally never work.
Which language? They have more than 20 official ones, you know.Quote:
Originally Posted by Seyerus1
Less than half of Indians speak Hindi and only 10% speak English
mute the people you don't understand and that will clear up any clutter.
they should just renande it international global, or multilingual global.Quote:
Originally Posted by Seyerus1
There definitely should be different globals especially for clans that have time zone specific war starts.
We start our wars at 4-6pm EST and don't want players who would be sleeping in the far east when the war ends and we need clean up attacks to fetch a couple more stars.
So we dont have to recruit players from far east zones.
We've had a few and they always complain the war starts when they sleeping and request to change it.
Our clan is inter, as we have players from canada, US, mexico, bahamas
On a separate note I had this conversation with a 15 year old in global who was recruiting for his clan. In his recruiting message, he mentioned NO INDIANS ( in caps).. I asked him why.. His notion of the country with a 1.2 billion population was that, all Indian clashers are "80 year old pedos who come to global to pick up little girls".
I couldn't figure out whether to laugh out at his ignorance, or be concerned that a 15 year old has these kind of notions about places which doesn't know anything about.
When did India's population drop to 300mil? I must have slept through a world war.Quote:
Originally Posted by TPS
Eh.. misquoted.. was thinking about my country's number while writing.. sorry!Quote:
Originally Posted by TooBizar4u
I never really see the need to go to global,
recruiting ?the forums are a much better place.
Looking for a clan?
The forums again .
Want to chat with people ?
The forums are here ,not to mention a Kik and line group where we just chat,and chat ,and ........well chat?
Not to mention the "Forum Events ' Clan ,where we are more active that global itself.
So I do not see why would anyone want to go to global,unless you yourself are looking for a girl,though we frequently have 'love black magic baba' spam posts,so you might wanna call one of them ;)
And hence ,global is only for kids,for12 year olds ,and you know how mature they can be !
Boom Beach and Clash Royale are doing well without a global,and I do not see why coc needs one either .
Over 422 million people in India reported Hindi to be their native language in 2001.Quote:
Originally Posted by Seyerus1
Best solution is add Hindi as a language to the game. SC has enough money to do this.
You are trump ,you werw,you are and you will be a LOSER. Period.Quote:
Originally Posted by DonaldJohnDrumpf
Netherlands has a population of 15 million, yet has it's own global. Is that racism? There are 10 languages in India that have over 30 million speakers, each. And, it's not just Indians. There are several linguistic groups who are bringing yuuge numbers of people to the game. This is a good thing! But, I'd think it would be make everyone's experience better if there were more global languages. Most people never come to this or any other forum besides global when looking for a clan.Quote:
Originally Posted by KarmicJustice
I've seen a few 'true norsk' get crabby about all the English speakers, lol. Maybe some SC should add some globals that allow only high trophies or people with large #s of war stars...Quote:
Originally Posted by KarmicJustice
I agree. Oh for the love of all that is not curry.Quote:
Originally Posted by Seyerus1
One of the National languages of india is english thats why they are on english global and why it wont change.
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonaldJohnDrumpf
This made my day :)
They don't need a Hindi language setting, just do what they did to Indonesians and others.
If i select English as my language, the global chat server will be Indonesian.
Some speculated that this is based on the IP address when you first installed the game.
However, if i select other language, the global chat server will be of that language.
I don't know why Indonesians don't choose English language, so that they are on Indonesian chat server.
I guess they wanted better recruits or something...
Adding an Indonesian language setting will be of no use if this is the case.
There is this amazing feature called the mute button
The problem as I experience it isn't just language per se. When I do out on global to chat and meet perspective members, I start getting requests from people in India and Bangladesh and they get offended when I politely decline their request to join. It has nothing to do with the language and everything to do with the time zone difference.
We have had several from India join us, but since they are not on when we are doing the biggest share of our raiding, they do not benefit from our troop donations and leave the clan sooner than later. I bring this up to those wishing to join, but it just doesn't sink in. Not sure if they need their own char or we just need chats based more on times zones
A guy from US was telling me, our country has all racist, horrible people... So that guy is god? No you are stoopeed.. US Rocks!Quote:
Originally Posted by TPS
No Sir, 50% of them would not write read Hindi. Our language is close to hindi but most of the education is in english. Hindi writting and reading was v v v tough. I could barely pass the exam for that 1 cultural hindi subject, spoken is easy...Quote:
Originally Posted by Purplefish
Infact if you speak of mobile/clash users... people who do not understand english would be so so v less... I do not go on global, but I would not pick hindi because its tough for me to read and write.. i dont even know how would I type it in hindi.
Idea will fail.. lot of people will not even select it.
These threads needs to close... There will come a point when this will get offensive and hatred will spill out...
Reporting to mods.......
You guys should make "love"Quote:
Originally Posted by Bankai05
-----------------------------------------------------------
Quote:
http://supercell-forum-content.s3.am...quote_icon.png Originally Posted by DonaldJohnDrumpf http://supercell-forum-content.s3.am...post-right.png
Seyerus, you have my unblinking full support on this.
Apparently, few folks like you and I, see the real problems this game has. We're losing to the indians and the indonesians. We've become full-time losers. When was the last time you spent a full minute in global without the annoying 'WKWKWK' or 'Indo Push' or 'Join Indo'? Our leaders have been failing tremendously securing our diversity and borders against these folks.
But we're the people who have what it takes to face these kinds of problems, for everyone's good. All these politically correct liberal hippies frame us as "Racists", but they don't know better, which prevents us to solving the problem. Look, I'm a really nice guy. I have a lot of Indian and Indonesian friends, that call me and say: "You know what Donald, you're right. We're in deep trouble here, our game is losing." They agree with me, and so should you.
So let's make this game great again, by giving indos/indians their own global. And if not, we'll build a wall around those folks, and make them pay for it.
Vote me, love me.
---------------------------------------------
I'm so ♥♥♥♥♥♥ right now, I can't find this post but I can find this thread... Mods say they do not want hatred and all the sheet... This thread speaks other wise
But this line (underline) made me laugh so bad... hahahahahahaah ROFLMAO... if you are good then god good is so UGLY!! absofreakinglutely ugly
True. I know how to talk in hindi. But i dont know how to write it.Quote:
Originally Posted by KingDLuffy
We in fact have no problem with other languages in our clan, but many may have. I cant understand anything what clan leader and his bro talks (marathi), they cant understand what me and my friends talk (bengali), still we talk with each other in english and hindi, and try to second guess the other's language and have a good laugh about it. Only abusive words are common in both languages lol.
Also, i can speak with many bangladeshis too, but for me, South Indians use a very different language which i cannot understand at all, and i usually switch globals when people talk in tamil or other such languages. For you, it looks same, just the way chinese, japanese and Korean look the same.
And, i use english on global by default. I wonder if the "Indian" global wont be spammed by "English" as of which you are speaking of. You see, unlike Europe, our country has not divided ourselves by language, so these all might be an alien notion to you. But its how our country is unique.
Now for why we dont want an Indian global. First of all, there is no single Indian language. So a language global wont be made. Leaving the semantics behind, this Indian global which you speak of will be mostly filled with english, like norsk global. Thus, its a waste of server space. Also, if servers get divided as per population, you will find yourselves with lesser servers than us, which is good. But if its just divided by half, our global will be seriously lagged. Many of our indian clans recruit from all around the world. Like ours is an international clan.
I don't understand, why is this thread alive? Ayan posted 14 minutes ago, It did not jump the que, but the people who posted in this can find it via their profile, like I did.
Ok your wish. guess I will just put up with it. Used to it here now...
We need a global for racists while we are at it.
Instead of realising that there are kids, trolls and ppl who want to find true love across borders, focusing on Indians or chinese or brazilians or europeans or americans (whatever gets your goat) shows a horrible lack of social grace and stark racism.
♥♥♥♥, way to NOT blow that right outta proportion... Facepalm...Quote:
Originally Posted by KarmicJustice
At least you guys can read some of your global. My global's nothing but Chinese (and mostly spambots). I'm in Hong Kong, so I automatically get the Chinese global.
You have to take all the sheet... either you put up or get lost is the message I get?Quote:
Originally Posted by ironhair
I think every language should have its own Global! well.. not EVERY language, but mainstream languages, if you get what I mean?
The original post has nothing to do with race. Bringing it down to that level is juvenile trolling, no more.
I simply asked that the second largest country, by population, on Earth be given its own Global. There may be 30+ languages in India, but many are minority and half the population speaks Hindi.
Some may still use the English Global, (or Norsk - the Norwegians seemed to stop complaining about the invasion of their Global a long time ago when they realised they had access to a lot of high level players) or the Dutch Global, I sometimes go on there because there's a lot of English speakers there, or even the German Global (I go there because I speak German).
They can go wherever they want but their own Global will hugely alleviate the issues that currently exist with the English speaking Global.
What do people have against Hindi ? Hindi is a beautiful language.
It's easy to read and write in Hindi. A five year old can write in Hindi.
For example: नमस्ते.
http://i.imgur.com/H78ObRN.jpg
For this reason Hindi should have its own Global.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Seyerus1
This much is easy for me too. when it gets regularly lot to be written and read, I cannot do it.. I have had hindi as my language subject for like every year in my 10 + 2 years of schooling.... We here in India using "smartphones" which is important to be part of clash, mostly do not even type in hindi.. There will be a small share of people who cannot type/read in english. (so small because, they will be not educated, education in india is in english predominately unless it's a poor family who can afford only local language, in that case they wont have smartphone) There is not a single campaign in mobile industry who even say that there is hindi typing in the system.Quote:
Originally Posted by Purplefish
Now that is a small percentage and not huge....
So the point is you cannot give global for small set of people...
There will be many many languages which will then should have global...
I believe Scottish is different then the english spoken in england. Infact Scottish needs global then.
What I do not understand is, why cannot people ignore.
If you think english has too many countries then ask for country wise chat system... or just stop going to global!
Just because you both do not talk ill, does not mean others don't.
I means dogs keep barking but why allow hatred to spread.
I'm v ♥♥♥♥♥♥ that thread is alive.
P.S. Oh yea dogs bark a lot.. dogs will be dogs you know
Why are you trying your darndest to take this personally? Why do you insist on using words like 'hatred' to try and imply racism where none exists?Quote:
Originally Posted by KingDLuffy
If you are Indian why wouldn't you want your own Global?
Every other major region/language has their own. China has two official languages, Mandarina and Cantonese and a myriad minor languages spoken there but they seem happy to have their own Global. Why wouldn't you be?
If your English is good then you can still head to the English speaking Global, you have the best of both worlds.
Like many today you seek to take offence and are quick to play the race card. Well buddy, you're barking up the wrong tree here.
As for the 'Scottish' language point! Lolololol
Great idea. If you are on an english chat. It means you should speak English. It's rude to speak a different language that others can't understand. Plus there's always alot of insults between Indians and non indians, it makes it difficult to recruit or have a decent conversation about war strategies etc. It just makes sense that if you are speaking a language that is not english you should not be on an English chat
That would be great if we have a choice between indian global and normal global.
Everytime when we wanna talk on global there would be 2 options as mentioned above.Like when we will click on global under global there will these 2 options.
That would help a lot to us Indians as it would increase the interaction between Indians and supercell will get more players for their game.
I fully agree with the OP. Those who think this is not a good idea are obviously not looking into it enough.
First let me say, I have Indians in my clan, and I do not have a problem with Indians at all. So do not assume this post is racist.
Now, there are obvious language barriers between Indians and those who speak English as a first language. Many Indians who join my clan struggle to comprehend a lot of the English spoken by the other clan members. No, this is not EVERY Indian, but it is a large number. Don't get me started on those who join and say 'plz donaet' and cannot speak English whatsoever. More on language barriers; when an indian member says 'give troops now' it sounds pretty darn rude. However, I understand that whilst sounding rude may not be the intention, it is still one of the many issues between many Indians and fluent English speakers.
Yes, a lot of my own clan issues would be solved if we simply recruited less Indians... But that is a tall task when much of the global is filled with Indian players. There are also many clans saying 'Only Indian Members!' or 'No Indians!'. Giving a separate global chat for Indian members would outright solve these issues.
Secondly, an issue is racism. Now, I am Australian, and many Australians are racist. I can accept that, and I disagree with it. So it is only fair when I address clear racism also coming from Indians as well. I have seen countless times where Indians have been slandering American, Australian and most of all British members on global. It is even worse when they join your clan and fill your chat with racist remarks. And even still, if the vile comments themselves are not racist, the motivation for writing them was. Whilst this does not happen on EVERY global, it is still an issue that needs to be addressed. Another thing is how the censors do not work for many Hindi and Tamil swear words. Which means Indians can freely swear on global with little to no repercussions, especially when they are directed at a native English speaker. Once again, adding a new global exclusive for Indian members would remove these issues of race from both parties.
I might add that a lot of racism has come from the fact that most of the English Global is made up of Indians. Simply, there are always going to be those people who are talking rubbish or swearing or generally being annoying. Unfortunately, because most of the global is Indian, most of those who are talking rubbish, swearing and being annoying ARE the Indians. Yes, I know that if Indians were not on the global these issues would still be present, but at least much of the racist stereotyping against Indians would be non-existent. (eg: All Indians are 80 year old pedos looking for girlfriends on COC)
Now, time to point out obvious flaws with the useless arguments presented against this idea.
One was that not all Indians speak the same language, so an Indian global would not make a difference / be a pointless addition. Well let me say this: it would be a hell of a lot better than them being on global speaking 20+ different languages to the ONLY place that fluent English speakers can visit to seek out new members or simple conversation. Whilst it may not immediately solve the language barriers between Indians who speak different languages, but it solves many issues between Indians and fluent English speakers. It also makes things easier for Indians who would rather speak their native language than English. Really it is kind of useless NOT to make a new global.
As for those who said 'what will stop them from staying on the English global anyway?', well to that my answer is 'Nothing'. But in saying that, it would still empty much of the English global from Indian members, and thus that it still a massive improvement. So basically, your comment implies that every different global chat is useless, because there is nothing stopping me from entering a French global, or a Dutch global. Well nothing is stopping me, but I'd rather be in the global where my own people are. Most of the Indians would make that same decision. If you disagree, well... you are entitled your opinion... My opinion is that you are not a logical thinker.
Another useless comment was that it is 'Global' chat so we should learn to be multicultural. Not sure how this makes sense... So that means all other global chats like the Russian and the German are useless and we should all be in one huge global where nobody can speak the same language? Ok...
Even if the Indians do get their own chat, it is still global. Americans, Canadians, Australians, British - they are all still making the Global Chat 'global'.
Simplest solution would be to have an English Global (for NATIVE English speakers, or FLUENT English speakers) and then a separate Indian Global (where all the Indians can go and just do their own thing). If you like talking with the Indians, join their Global. Not hard to do.
Honestly right now this issue needs to be addressed more than anything else. I can't imagine it's incredibly hard to do. Farming was axed to make the game more enjoyable for everyone, why cant a new global be opened for the same reason?
I do genuinely believe that there should be seperate globals! If people had a choice of where they could recruit, it would be much easier. I would like to say that it could just be a an age issue?!? But I fear I would be branded ageist!
I have no issues with any nationality, we all have pros and cons and we are all playing the same game. But when I log on to english global....I kind of expect to see english being used, this is not the case
I recruit from global, and have met some great players. But as someone else pointed out a polite no thank you can result in a tirade of abuse.
Being female i also fall foul of insults. Most pretty disgusting if I am honest. Yes I could change my name (its a regular name, not easy girl or suchlike) to Steve or Frank, but why should I? We are in 2016.
Perhaps the supercell staff / moderators should pop into English global and see what happens and judge for themselves.
+1 for Indian relocation.
No buddy thats racist im also an Indian but giving ourselve a chat in coc is too racist... They cant give it to one country right... Bad idea actually...
But bro if supercell makes a separate global only fr Indians... Many other countries would also want their own global... Now coc cant make over 190 globals right... So better be gud to everyone in the global... Im an Indian... I love my country nd RESPECT other country ppl... If they are good to me... :)Quote:
Originally Posted by LucasHood
Whether or not it makes sense, it's the best suggestion i've seen in a while.
You go into global and say hi without a clan and within 10 seconds you have 15 Indians begging you to join their clan and they will even give you co. If you say no, they then turn aggressive, fire insults and when you give them the same treatment it's a different story. However, the amount of Indians who claim to have 'done' my mother makes me wonder why my dad isn't Indian :unsure:
Also, when a girl pops up in chat, dear God it's like 15 hormonal teens have been let loose from their mothers basement. If Indians had their own chat, my globals would be much more pleasant to be in. Sadly it won't happen I don't think so it's one of few dreams I have.
I see only english and indo in norsk and english all the time. In norsk I never see norsk speaking people.Quote:
Originally Posted by Namess
Indians are perhaps the largest community on CoC. It only makes sense to give them their own global. Because India makes up such a large portion of the CoC community, nobody would dispute the fact that they should get their own Global. I doubt EVERY country will want their own global chat if India is given it's own. People want to be in a global where they can speak their own language.Quote:
Originally Posted by Anurag01
I have been insulted by a vast number of Indians on the English global for asking them to speak English. If Indians would rather speak their own language, then why is it such a bad idea that they should get their own global?
Did you read my post? Do you understand my point of view? There are more reasons to support the creation of an Indian global than to dispute it. Racism and Language Barriers are two massive issues that would be resolved if India was given it's own global. That is not an opinion, that is a fact.
You said this was a bad idea? I don't see how it is. If you read all the posts supporting this argument you would see how it is clearly not racist and it is a well thought out and very good idea. Actually it is the best idea I have heard in a long time.
You think this idea is racist? Read my post again. Giving India it's own global removes racism on both sides. You may respect other country ppl, unfortunately that is not the case for everyone on global, including many Indians.
It's not good , Try your best as I am in top of Nepal but never been to Global!!
I believe that if we had the option to swap between global chat rooms, it may resolve many of these issues. You could then keep searching until you found a room with like minded people whom you could enjoy a conversation with.
Rather than segregating people, just give us the ability to leave a global chat without leaving the game.
I, tbh, am tired of reading 'wkwkwk' every time I go on global, not that I have an issue with them, but they wouldn't communicate, they need their own global just to feel important in a way that they know they can do freely on their global without disturbing others, (please censor 'wkwkwk'😂)
(If you haven't noticed, I'm not being entirely serious)
Quote:
Originally Posted by LucasHood
Yes!!!
LucasHood has expressed everything I wanted to but couldn't.
Not to mention a few other things that I see on global that need to be addressed, but this seems to be an issue that I agree with, and that's the language barrier, if this is a "quality of life" change, which they claimed to have been doing over a roll of updates, then supercell should look into this.Quote:
Originally Posted by LucasHood
Quote:
Originally Posted by AyanD
One thing though, if you say that India has more than 20 languages, then why not an Indian global? Is their an issue? If there are people of an Indian language that you can not comprehend, then refresh the game, you could say the same for the English speakers, but (no offense) Indians are everywhere, I could refresh the game, but there would always be an Indian ranting or cussing someone out, poking, bullying, speaking their native tongue, being rude and/ oroffensive, and/ or purposely triggering others (I laugh on the other hand lol) the other regular more relaxed Indians would actually try to make them stop, but hey kinda fall for the trolling acts, others literally laugh or mock others, but mute is there as well.... I guess.....
No reason to beat around the bush.. Indians are trouble and unaccepted in general wherever they go in game or in person. It's the culture which is incompatible with advanced society. They didn't join the rest of the world and now they are behind. Now this being said it's not fully Indians just the majority. I'm not racist in any way but not dumb either, I have a few Indian friends who are OK but like anybody reading this will agree with, they are few and far between. If supercell won't deal with he problem they leave the players do it and this results in hatred between the races and related comments. All English should go back to English and take it back. Harass the Indians right out of the globals as they have done to others. If u r english use english if u r norsk use norsk, easy.
English went to norsk because norsk was small and Indians / young players were absent. Now that everybody knows of it the Indians / young players have invaded. And this hasn't even touched on the fact that now the claim should be from norsk complaining about English. So what's next? English players move to French? Or maybe some other crazy language that makes the buttons not possible to understand. Now norsk is a festering of Muslim related comments, Indian troop beggars, and Asian adverts. It's gonna happen over and over global by global trouble with Indians.
I don't understand that are u against Indians or this post. Clearly mention the thing you wanna say in few words.Quote:
Originally Posted by ajunky
even Iranians got their own global .
This is why people say there are language barriers... Now, to me, this post clearly states the thing he wants to say. Just because he has elaborated does not mean it doesn't make any sense. In fact it makes more sense than a single sentence would.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mukundgpt30
That is how you win arguments: by elaborating and providing an extended response as opposed to a single sentence or two. I still don't understand how effort isn't being made to give the Indians their own global. The arguments for seem to way outclass the arguments against. Everyone who disagrees with this can't seem to back up their argument, and so we have comments left right and center about how this is a "bad idea" and it is "racist". To all those people, please refer to my original post on Page 5, and see why this idea is clearly a great one.
I think people confuse language with race sometimes. Asking that an Indian global can be created is not racist. Language is not race. While some may turn this racist, that is not the OP's intent nor the intent of most of the people suggesting it.
I'm always on Norsk. I meet alot of ignorant people who tend to talk about their beverages and holidays on Norsk as well so, the type of clashers who say stuff like "Your base isn't up to scratch Hun". They have normal, civilised conversations then all of a sudden, a Donald Trump demon arises inside of them when an Indonesian comes on, then another, and another.
The ignorant bunch say "Go to your own chat! This is an English only chat!"
Norsk: Norweigan language (currently full of ignorant Caucasians with no tolerance or acceptance of other people's language. They even took the audacity to pillage and steal the whole chat room"
Global: a Global chat full of English, Afrikaans, French, German, Italian, Indonesian, Indian and Philippines clashers.
If you can't enjoy other cultures or even tolerate them, why are you even playing Clash?
This is a Finnish game with a Japanese robot fighting mythical creatures.
Get over yourself.
I'm not sure why this thread hasn't been pinned or closed.
This is just devolving into a racist thread about a particular community.
Every person making a racist or derogatory comment should be banned.
Hell, ppl are digging out their old 2014 created spam accounts to post here... bah.
Edit - I just opened this thread and the 1st post I read was one of 6 days old, a post that only served to leave me with a bad taste, thanks to it's racist overtures and insults.