Increasing clan members idea *

Many people had suggested more members for each clan , so here's the idea for increasing clan members , SC shouldn't just increase max members of a clan , so create a feature that allow people extend their clan ...
here the lv of clan :
+ lv1 : 50members (same as now)
+ lv2 : 60members
+ lv3 : 70 members
+lv4 : 80 members
+lv5 :90 members
+ lv6 :100 members

Lv 6 should be max lv !!! Each clan lv up by donating resources (Note* it's not donating resources to other players) , each lv of clan :players can donate both gold n elixir , first time : 1k , second : 10k , third : 50k etc. so it would just go higher n higher , so only 1 player can't upgrade clan , it required all clan members to help n upgrade their own clan ...
Any feed back? No offense pls :)

Like the idea. Would really be a HUGE addition to the game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kingliam725

Like the idea. Would really be a HUGE addition to the game.

---

Thank you :)

i think it would basically help clans with gemmers though. it would mess up the rankings for a long time as clans with lots of gemmers would go to the top and the rest of the clans who don't spend tons of money on this game would not be ranked and it would kind of ruin trophy pushing. however it would make supercell some money so idk.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kylar

i think it would basically help clans with gemmers though. it would mess up the rankings for a long time as clans with lots of gemmers would go to the top and the rest of the clans who don't spend tons of money on this game would not be ranked and it would kind of ruin trophy pushing. however it would make supercell some money so idk.

---

Um without this feature , gemmers clan still on the top , have u ever seen a farmer clan go to top 10? Ofcos it's never :)
n it requires resources to upgrade clan , n what do farmers have the most? Resources ofcos :) so its not only for gemmers ...

gemmers don't need to farm they would just buy resources to donate instantly. where as farming clans would have to take time to get up the levels. and weren't you in the clan the outfit with lost carrot as leader? lol

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kylar

gemmers don't need to farm they would just buy resources to donate instantly. where as farming clans would have to take time to get up the levels. and weren't you in the clan the outfit with lost carrot as leader? lol

---

Yep for sure farmers would take time to get up the levels just like they take time to build up their bases :)
yes I was there before

lol interesting. I was there with you. still in that clan now. but it would just outrage a lot of players who do not gem as they would not like that gemming clans can just so easily take over the rankings. and it would ruin trophy pushing for any clan that is not lvl 6.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kylar

lol interesting. I was there with you. still in that clan now. but it would just outrage a lot of players who do not gem as they would not like that gemming clans can just so easily take over the rankings. and it would ruin trophy pushing for any clan that is not lvl 6.

---

Yep I see u there.
I think hardcore farmers wouldn't think this is hard for them , for simple farmers can do this time by time , they can hardly get to top 200 tho

right not so hard for hardcore farmers and gemmers. but this game is mass appealing. there are many casual players who would see this as an unfair advantage. gamers may start to see super cell turning into an anti casual money grubbing company which it is not. but this may change some opinions.

I like this, but levels should be unlocked by clan trophy count.

ok I can get on board with the lvls being linked to clan trophy count. as long as you could not go down in level. I like this because it would add some more importance to trophies. and give clans a real reason to trophy push besides just trying to see how high they could get.

I don't think this would work because it would totally screw up the clan leader boards

it would for a small amount of time yes maybe. but it would probably settle back down because the top clans would already be lvl 6 or whatever the highest lvl would be and they would recruit and get themselves back to the top with maybe some minor shifting. this would also give more people a chance to join the top clans.

So, if to farmers it will be too easy, to gemmers it will be SUPER easy, why not having a donate limit?
Like: Donate max of 100k gold per day (Don`t must to donate 100k, but its your maximum)

Or just with trophy count like someone said..

The idea is really good, but its true gemmers will do it muce more easily if there wont be a limit!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Adir

So, if to farmers it will be too easy, to gemmers it will be SUPER easy, why not having a donate limit?
Like: Donate max of 100k gold per day (Don`t must to donate 100k, but its your maximum)

Or just with trophy count like someone said..

The idea is really good, but its true gemmers will do it muce more easily if there wont be a limit!

---

Yep I think there should be a limit for each player!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kylar

right not so hard for hardcore farmers and gemmers. but this game is mass appealing. there are many casual players who would see this as an unfair advantage. gamers may start to see super cell turning into an anti casual money grubbing company which it is not. but this may change some opinions.

---

I saw many people request for more members , so this is just an idea on how to increase that...

I understand people want more members but if you tye it to resources you would have to make it a high number like 40 million for lvl 2 and so on so it was not so easy to achieve otherwise what is the point. I do not think there should be a limit because if there is than the effect would just take to long to hit the game.

like I have said before I believe it should be based off of trophy level thus making more or a purpose for trophies and trophy pushing for a clan. and this way you would not ♥♥♥♥ off the non gemmers.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kylar

I understand people want more members but if you tye it to resources you would have to make it a high number like 40 million for lvl 2 and so on so it was not so easy to achieve otherwise what is the point. I do not think there should be a limit because if there is than the effect would just take to long to hit the game.

like I have said before I believe it should be based off of trophy level thus making more or a purpose for trophies and trophy pushing for a clan. and this way you would not ♥♥♥♥ off the non gemmers.

---

The amount needed to upgrade would be increase higher n higher depends on clan lv . N if it based off trophies then what will happen to other 10 members if the clan lv decrease ? Auto-kick out?

I posted earlier that the clan lvl would not decrease. like I said it would be cool because your clan would set a goal for a trophy push to get to the next clan lvl. then you could get more memebers and go back to farming. and when you think you are ready attempt the next lvl. and I understand you would want to increase the amount the resources per lvl. I started with 40 million because that would really only take 5 people with make resources or 5 people willing to spend money on gems to get max resources then go to 80million then 160 then 320. however I still think that would be not smart and also ruin the ability for people to make new clans. because no one would want to join a new clan that can only hold 50 members and it would take forever to raise the lvl with just resources even if it was top players. but if it is based on trophy count then top players creating a new clan would not be held back.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kylar

I posted earlier that the clan lvl would not decrease. like I said it would be cool because your clan would set a goal for a trophy push to get to the next clan lvl. then you could get more memebers and go back to farming. and when you think you are ready attempt the next lvl. and I understand you would want to increase the amount the resources per lvl. I started with 40 million because that would really only take 5 people with make resources or 5 people willing to spend money on gems to get max resources then go to 80million then 160 then 320. however I still think that would be not smart and also ruin the ability for people to make new clans. because no one would want to join a new clan that can only hold 50 members and it would take forever to raise the lvl with just resources even if it was top players. but if it is based on trophy count then top players creating a new clan would not be held back.

---

That's y I said it should be limited , so all members must donate to get their clan lv up ... N yes , it would be hard to encourage people to join a new clan

like I said basing clan lvls based on trophy count would be cooler and a better system than resource donating and placing a cap on it per member.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kylar

like I said basing clan lvls based on trophy count would be cooler and a better system than resource donating and placing a cap on it per member.

---

Yep , that could work as well :)