Printable View
more and more clans are bring to spys to other clans and i know its our fault for accepting people when war have a war going on but there is clans that still need to recruit and dont know who is a spy and who is not
so to fix this problem
war spectators should not be able see traps that has no negative impact on the game so on the poll say yes this should happen or is a bad idea
If you have your clan set on request, and search out new recruits and ask them to mention you or a code word in the application request then it's problem solved.
I think it should be this: Anyone who joins after a war match is made cannot see traps for only that war. that means that anyone who joins before matches are made (only potential spies, as they cannot join enemy clan before they know who enemy clan is). however, people who have been there since before the match was made (cannot be a spy unless clan somehow knows they will match that clan before they do, which is either time travel, really small pool, or psychic powers)
If this is truly a problem just set the clan to invite only. Then only request people who you invited or know aren't on the other side. If you see a request and don't know then just leave it sit there till the end of war. If they truly want in then they will wait.
In my opinion, spies are just a way for the enemy to scare you into thinking that theyre gonna win because they have pointless and meaningless screenshots that wont help or hurt either side at all.
You have a valid point mate even wit a screen shoot of your bases they have still got to do the business of winning!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by zoelem
Must admit I have totally changed my view on this topic since I joined the forum. I used to think spying was just a bit of fun and nothing to become overly concerned with. I now realise that for clans who war back to back it makes it far more difficult to recruit if you are always concerned about spies or even keeping the settings on 'closed'. With some clans I see that this is leading to a slow dieing out of the clan as ppl leave and can't be replaced. I do agree we need some sort of solution to help keep these clans alive, thereby giving more incentive to stay in the game, and therefore helping SC as well as the community.
I want to run a hybrid clan of war/req n leave for mostly maxed players. Obviously closing the clan wouldn't work with req n leave. The best solution I can think of is warring twice a week, therefore closing the clan for 4 days and leaving only 3 days for req n leave.
I wish SC would address this problem. Perhaps allowing only people in war roster to access clan wars and giving leaders the ability to add members to war rosters as spectators explicitly.
its not that easy
I totally agree and feel that this is a huge problem. Check out this idea by hdogger777. http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-Spies-ProblemI think you'll agree and many other will or already do:)