Scarlett letter?

I know we fair play members have been waiting for this day but let's not start building the guillotine yet. Give them a two week ban and let's move onward.

A temporary one might be helpful. As a leader, I would like to know if my new member was involved in that. I don't want to bring someone into war and they try something and get banned again in war. Maybe keep it until they have had a dozen mod free wars or something like that.

[QUOTE=PrincessKeys;7220657]A temporary one might be helpful. As a leader, I would like to know if my new member was involved in that. I don't want to bring someone into war and they try something and get banned again in war. Maybe keep it until they have had a dozen mod free wars or something like that.[/QUi

I agree with u permanent would be too much but for the tine they are banned would begreat

[QUOTE=tmoneyisback;7220698]

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PrincessKeys

A temporary one might be helpful. As a leader, I would like to know if my new member was involved in that. I don't want to bring someone into war and they try something and get banned again in war. Maybe keep it until they have had a dozen mod free wars or something like that.[/QUi

I agree with u permanent would be too much but for the tine they are banned would begreat

---

Yes I agree with this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheJager

I dont really like the idea of a mark on their profiles cuz they'll probably become outcasts then. no clan will accept them...that is a bit too harsh a punishment even for modding. But what imo wud be better is if there's a sign showing if they r banned currently....like a red"BANNED" on their profile.

---

This is a much better idea very solid point

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PrincessKeys

A temporary one might be helpful. As a leader, I would like to know if my new member was involved in that. I don't want to bring someone into war and they try something and get banned again in war. Maybe keep it until they have had a dozen mod free wars or something like that.

---

Not a modder but this is getting out of hand. As others have said, do the crime do the time. After that you are free as long as you don't have a second strike. So is there a chance you take someone and they get permanently banned, sure. It's going to be a low risk and there are many other reasons someone could miss a war that should be of greater concern. It is just not that big of a deal and easily managed.

Seek justice, not vengeance. Huge difference between the two.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Martvol

Seek justice, not vengeance. Huge difference between the two.

---

Sounds like batman.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by fieldofdreams

Not a modder but this is getting out of hand. As others have said, do the crime do the time. After that you are free as long as you don't have a second strike. So is there a chance you take someone and they get permanently banned, sure. It's going to be a low risk and there are many other reasons someone could miss a war that should be of greater concern. It is just not that big of a deal and easily managed.

---

I agree. Supercell is already keeping official records, so they can dole out larger punishments for repeat offenders; there is no reason to continue punishing someone who has already served their official sentence, as long as they keep their nose clean from that point on.

I do like the idea of showing someone as being banned while they're banned, though, as it would allow clan members to differentiate between those in time-out and people who are truly inactive.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sj74

They will form clans together....a sort of leper colony.

---

He he he..I Like it my friend, we should make them carry bells.....'Unclean, Unclean'