Clash of clans have should have

Printable View

April 23rd, 2016
WILLIYBOYZZ

Clash of clans have should have

They need a friendly battle mode like in a clan battle clan mates
April 23rd, 2016
AliDaBeast21

Could you please explain a bit more? How would this actually work?

also, this belongs in IFR
April 23rd, 2016
fthandy

Its to easy to exploit!
April 23rd, 2016
Boardname

Quote:

Originally Posted by fthandy

Its to easy to exploit!

What would it exploit?
April 23rd, 2016
SansTheSkeletonPlaysCLash

Quote:

Originally Posted by WILLIYBOYZZ

They need a friendly battle mode like in a clan battle clan mates

This is interesting
April 23rd, 2016
Kuris

Quote:

Originally Posted by SansTheSkeletonPlaysCLash

This is interesting

SansTheSkeletonHasALongName

Also, this idea is commonly suggested, it's even made its way on to the sticky thread at the top of this page! Please read them before posting, you know it makes sense.
April 23rd, 2016
Deadtoast15

I do not believe this idea would be implemented.

Reason: Your friend could make your opponent's war base and attack it over and over again until 3 star.

I understand that this could be a fun idea but it could easily be exploited in this way.
April 23rd, 2016
Kuris

Quote:

Originally Posted by Deadtoast15

I do not believe this idea would be implemented.

Reason: Your friend could make your opponent's war base and attack it over and over again until 3 star.

I understand that this could be a fun idea but it could easily be exploited in this way.

Maybe have the feature automatically deactivate during war?
April 23rd, 2016
CannonFodder413

Quote:

Originally Posted by EpicChris

Maybe have the feature automatically deactivate during war?

You could still do it on an alt account
April 23rd, 2016
Deadtoast15

Quote:

Originally Posted by CannonFodder413

You could still do it on an alt account

Exactly. This is why it is not a viable option for this idea.
April 23rd, 2016
Kuris

Quote:

Originally Posted by CannonFodder413

You could still do it on an alt account

But if said alt account isn't in the same clan as you, then you can't challenge it to a duel

and if it is in the same clan as you, then you can not challenge it to a duel during war

so you'd need two alts. Both on high levels

you can also limit how many duels are allowed in a period of time
April 23rd, 2016
SansTheSkeletonPlaysCLash

Quote:

Originally Posted by EpicChris

SansTheSkeletonHasALongName

Also, this idea is commonly suggested, it's even made its way on to the sticky thread at the top of this page! Please read them before posting, you know it makes sense.

What do you mean?
April 23rd, 2016
JimTwig

I posted my idea about this in another post that got buried so will repost it here!

This is something I've been thinking about too as a possible game feature. Here's my idea of how it could work.

I will call it an 'Internal Clan War' (I will use ICW for short) so basically is a war between all members in your clan. Each ICW would last for 1 week and every clans war reset at the same time. I think it lasting a week or even possible more would stop people using this to copy bases from clan wars and practising on them.

At the start you select your war base as like in normal wars (obviously traps would not be visible to others). As for cc troops I would suggest that you can select your own to the max level your clan can donate. So if your clan can donate max drags you can choose a max drag for your cc, if your clan can only donate lv4 that's the level that you will get. This way nobody else knows what's in your cc and seems fair.

Now for the war part. I think each player would have say, 5 ( or maybe 10!) attacks each. A winning attack would gain you points and everyone would be in a mini league table for the ICW. Now to keep things fair between the high and low town hall levels I would have the points system based on how hard the base your attacking is. So if your a th10 and decided to go for easy attacks and smash your th7 buddies you would only get 1 point for 3 starring them. But as a th10 if you decided to hit a th11 and 3 star you would get significantly more points, less points if you 2 starred and less again for 1 star. This would mean you could finish the war at the top even as a lower town hall as the points awarded are based on the the defensive strength of the bases you attacked.

I think this would encourage people to try hitting the higher bases for more points, but not too high so as to fail and get nothing.

NO replays would be available during the war except to the person who's base was attacked. This will stop others knowing about the traps and cc troops. Replays could possibly be available to view for a short period once the war has ended.

Troops costs for the ICW would be refunded so people are not losing out on resources and more loot can be given out as prizes (say 1million gold/elix and 5k DE for finishing top as an example) and decreasing as you finish lower down. This will also generate more loot in the game overall, albeit a fairly small amount.

I'm sure there are flaws to this and it might be to big to even implement but I think it would be a nice addition to the game, keeping people playing longer, getting more attacks in and helping the social aspect of the game too.

Please don't scald me too hard if you don't like the idea, as it will likely never happen anyway!

Any other thoughts on how the idea could be improved?
April 23rd, 2016
Deadtoast15

Quote:

Originally Posted by JimTwig

I posted my idea about this in another post that got buried so will repost it here!

This is something I've been thinking about too as a possible game feature. Here's my idea of how it could work.

I will call it an 'Internal Clan War' (I will use ICW for short) so basically is a war between all members in your clan. Each ICW would last for 1 week and every clans war reset at the same time. I think it lasting a week or even possible more would stop people using this to copy bases from clan wars and practising on them.

At the start you select your war base as like in normal wars (obviously traps would not be visible to others). As for cc troops I would suggest that you can select your own to the max level your clan can donate. So if your clan can donate max drags you can choose a max drag for your cc, if your clan can only donate lv4 that's the level that you will get. This way nobody else knows what's in your cc and seems fair.

Now for the war part. I think each player would have say, 5 ( or maybe 10!) attacks each. A winning attack would gain you points and everyone would be in a mini league table for the ICW. Now to keep things fair between the high and low town hall levels I would have the points system based on how hard the base your attacking is. So if your a th10 and decided to go for easy attacks and smash your th7 buddies you would only get 1 point for 3 starring them. But as a th10 if you decided to hit a th11 and 3 star you would get significantly more points, less points if you 2 starred and less again for 1 star. This would mean you could finish the war at the top even as a lower town hall as the points awarded are based on the the defensive strength of the bases you attacked.

I think this would encourage people to try hitting the higher bases for more points, but not too high so as to fail and get nothing.

NO replays would be available during the war except to the person who's base was attacked. This will stop others knowing about the traps and cc troops. Replays could possibly be available to view for a short period once the war has ended.

Troops costs for the ICW would be refunded so people are not losing out on resources and more loot can be given out as prizes (say 1million gold/elix and 5k DE for finishing top as an example) and decreasing as you finish lower down. This will also generate more loot in the game overall, albeit a fairly small amount.

I'm sure there are flaws to this and it might be to big to even implement but I think it would be a nice addition to the game, keeping people playing longer, getting more attacks in and helping the social aspect of the game too.

Please don't scald me too hard if you don't like the idea, as it will likely never happen anyway!

Any other thoughts on how the idea could be improved?

I suggest actually creating a thread about your idea. It makes no sense to post your idea in a comment section of another idea. If you don't know how to ask me and I'll show you step by step.
April 23rd, 2016
JimTwig

Quote:

Originally Posted by Deadtoast15

I suggest actually creating a thread about your idea. It makes no sense to post your idea in a comment section of another idea. If you don't know how to ask me and I'll show you step by step.

Thanks, I think I will. I'm glad you think the idea is good enough to deserve it's own thread and not just be buried!
April 23rd, 2016
IcewolfBlizzard

You could exploit it for war by copying an enemies' base. Don't see it happening, but seems great otherwise.
April 24th, 2016
Boardname

Quote:

Originally Posted by IcewolfBlizzard

You could exploit it for war by copying an enemies' base. Don't see it happening, but seems great otherwise.

You cant place traps and correct cc troops in it anyway. You can already assume how far a troop can get in. No exploiting here