Solution for War Spies Problem

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hdogger777

In our clan we have a lot of paranoia about accepting new members during war. There is fear that a new joiner during war is a Spy for our war opponent. We usually have to set our clan to Closed status during war but we sometimes forget. Worse, sometimes an Elder will accept a new member during war, they stay about 5 minutes, then leave, and everybody is wondering if they took screen shots of every Warbase.

I thought of an easy solution for this issue. In addition to our existing roles of WAR PARTICIPANT, and WAR SPECTATOR, I propose a new role of WAR VISITOR. A person shall be assigned the WAR VISITOR role if they join a clan during Prep day or Battle day of war. The WAR VISITOR role shall not be able to see any traps, teslas, or hidden features of any warbase (same view the enemy team gets). The WAR VISITOR role shall not be able to see what the contents are of the War Clan Castles, nor shall they be able to see what is requested for donation to War Castles. Therefore the WAR VISITOR shall be able to gain NO additional information than what the enemy team in war already has, nullifying the issue of War Spies.

---

War spies dont help out a lot. All they do is make the enemy paranoia and cause them to worry about avoiding some seeking air mine or something.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by zoelem

War spies dont help out a lot. All they do is make the enemy paranoia and cause them to worry about avoiding some seeking air mine or something.

---

I am sorry but you are completely wrong. I am only guessing that you're a low town hall level, and don't know what is going on at higher town hall level attacks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dorsan

Best answer ever. I got this 'in a real war' argument several times, but never managed to make an answer quite as good as this one.

You are officially my hero now.

---

thank you.

I have never understood the desire to bring realism to a fantasy game, or movie.
The great thing about fantasy is you can do anything you want.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Whatare

there are no dragons in real war

---

Dragons aren't playing the game, humans are, there are humans in a real war, there are spies in a real war. Humans act as said spies.

yes its unsportsmanlike, but that happens in games, people are going to go out of their way to help themselves, if you're that concerned about spies, close up entry to your alliance during war times.

its really not a problem.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EpicChris

Dragons aren't playing the game, humans are, there are humans in a real war, there are spies in a real war. Humans act as said spies.

yes its unsportsmanlike, but that happens in games, people are going to go out of their way to help themselves, if you're that concerned about spies, close up entry to your alliance during war times.

its really not a problem.

---

I know not what these humans" are, I am an elf you are a troll.

seriouly, this is a fantasy GAME. This is not war.

Humans die in war. So by you logic, everyone that loses a war should be killed because that happens to humans in war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EpicChris

if you're that concerned about spies, close up entry to your alliance during war times.

its really not a problem.

---

It is really a problem.

We war back to back, can't have the clan closed 24/7.

As I said no one has a real solution that can work for casual clans, therefore it is up to SuperCell to fix this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nico201214

In a real war, THERE ARE SPIES !!!!! :thumbsup:

---

in real wars spies can be imprisoned, tortured, and even put to death. Should supercell allow us to do that too?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dorsan

It is really a problem.

We war back to back, can't have the clan closed 24/7.

As I said no one has a real solution that can work for casual clans, therefore it is up to SuperCell to fix this.

---

It is up to the clan to fix it. You can recruit people yourself from global or on the forums. You don't need to open up your clan for people to join. And you will always have that little bit of extra time between each war when you are searching etc. my clan has never really had a problem with spies (after the first time) because we learnt our lesson and dealt with it ourselves.

All is is fair in love and war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zaneth98

It is up to the clan to fix it.

---

Ok, how?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zaneth98

You can recruit people yourself from global or on the forums.

---

I had a recruitment thread going on the forums without getting a single recruit. If I go to global people just talk arabic or burmese, and if there is that one rare guy that speaks english and I do recruit them, they are horrible without exception. So, no, I can't recruit from the forum and neither can I recruit from the global.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zaneth98

And you will always have that little bit of extra time between each war when you are searching etc. my clan has never really had a problem with spies (after the first time) because we learnt our lesson and dealt with it ourselves.

---

That little bit of extra time? You mean 2-5 minutes per 48 hours?..

Ok you dealth with it. How?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zaneth98

All is is fair in love and war.

---

This is a game. Not a love and neither is it a war.1


And even if there would be things I could really do (which there aren't any), why should I be the one that needs to put in extra effort and why is it made so easy for those who don't care about sportsmanship?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dorsan

Ok, how?


I had a recruitment thread going on the forums without getting a single recruit. If I go to global people just talk arabic or burmese, and if there is that one rare guy that speaks english and I do recruit them, they are horrible without exception. So, no, I can't recruit from the forum and neither can I recruit from the global.


That little bit of extra time? You mean 2-5 minutes per 48 hours?..

Ok you dealth with it. How?


This is a game. Not a love and neither is it a war.1


And even if there would be things I could really do (which there aren't any), why should I be the one that needs to put in extra effort and why is it made so easy for those who don't care about sportsmanship?

---

Just recruit on norsk. I mean thats where all the non-noobs, like me, are at.