Should shielding not work against revenge?

Printable View

April 16th, 2016
Redhulk

Should shielding not work against revenge?

What do you guys think?
April 16th, 2016
wilsonatore

Quote:

Originally Posted by Redhulk

What do you guys think?

Of course it should, otherwise what's the point of shields? Every time you had mass loot saved for an upgrade, it would disappear quite quickly. No one targets the broke guy. Casual players would never amass anything. System is fine as is. Never a moment when at least a third of my possible revenge candidates are available for such. The whales are available less often only because...no one hits the broke guy.
April 16th, 2016
plab

Methinks gemmers (aka whales) who pay for all those shields to stay in the upper leagues would be up in arms if this were the case. Not gonna happen.
April 16th, 2016
slickYBF

Quote:

Originally Posted by plab

Methinks gemmers (aka whales) who pay for all those shields to stay in the upper leagues would be up in arms if this were the case. Not gonna happen.

You obviously don't understand the upper leagues. If you think they just jam shields up their you're insane, it takes a lot of attacks to stay relevant in Titan/legend.
April 16th, 2016
ironhair
Quote:

Originally Posted by Redhulk

What do you guys think?

It shouldn't.

Let revenge attacks get through once or twice a day through shields... or allow ONE hour a day after the PBT where only revenge attacks are allowed.

What's the point of revenge otherwise, if the other guy or you are always behind a VG, shield or online?
And when you do get kicked off, those 30 guys who want to revenge you are in the same pool as 1000s of other guys who are matchmaking normally?

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...ets-you-attack
Quote:
Originally Posted by ironhair

30 targets in attack log available for revenge attacks.
99% times hidden behind shield, guard or are online.
No way to know when target is open. Have to check manually
No quick information or way to check which is best target to hit
Suggest a fix that allows you to hit ONE (or two) people on the list of 30, EVEN if they are behind a shield.

Unless there's a notification saying "REVENGE AVAILABLE" and alerts us with some signal on the inbox / attack log page, revenge is kinda pointless and broken.

Ever since I started playing 14 months ago, I can't remember when out of the 30 available revenge targets, even 1 or 2 are open to attack.
They are all hidden behind shields, guards or are online.

I suggest that players get (one or two) open ended revenge attacks a day.
This will allow you to attack even if the enemy is behind a shield (obviously limited to people in your revenge list).

Also, there has to be an easier way to decide who take revenge on.
I want to see how much loot and trophy is available to me, across the list of the 30 targets, without having to check by clicking attack on each person individually or scouting them/visiting their village.
April 16th, 2016
slickYBF

I think the Revenge available option in the revenge log is viable and a good option to look at.
April 16th, 2016
AxionXD

One thing I've always said about revenge for a long time is this: The easier it is to revenge someone, the easier it will be to be revenged. I don't know about you, but I have far more people that I've pillaged and looking for payback than I have that I really want to revenge.

The more active you are, the more defense logs you'll appear on.

If you make it basically instantly available by bypassing the shield, you'll get revenged often and hard. It may actually cause the concept of Turtling from Boom Beach and bring it to Clash as people become afraid of attacking and end up farming off their revenge list...
April 16th, 2016
plab

Quote:

Originally Posted by slickYBF

You obviously don't understand the upper leagues. If you think they just jam shields up their you're insane, it takes a lot of attacks to stay relevant in Titan/legend.

Haven't you heard? You can attack behind shields now.
April 16th, 2016
ironhair

Quote:

Originally Posted by AxionXD

One thing I've always said about revenge for a long time is this: The easier it is to revenge someone, the easier it will be to be revenged. I don't know about you, but I have far more people that I've pillaged and looking for payback than I have that I really want to revenge.

The more active you are, the more defense logs you'll appear on.

If you make it basically instantly available by bypassing the shield, you'll get revenged often and hard. It may actually cause the concept of Turtling from Boom Beach and bring it to Clash as people become afraid of attacking and end up farming off their revenge list...

Which is why I am suggesting that attacking through the shields be allowed only once or twice a day.

I'm fine with that, as it makes revenge a viable concept.

Note, that I'm in a high league that trophies do matter.. and I am active enough that I'm in tons of defence logs of players.
I'm still in favor of a slight buff to the revenge button.
April 16th, 2016
wilsonatore

Quote:

Originally Posted by AxionXD

One thing I've always said about revenge for a long time is this: The easier it is to revenge someone, the easier it will be to be revenged. I don't know about you, but I have far more people that I've pillaged and looking for payback than I have that I really want to revenge.

The more active you are, the more defense logs you'll appear on.

If you make it basically instantly available by bypassing the shield, you'll get revenged often and hard. It may actually cause the concept of Turtling from Boom Beach and bring it to Clash as people become afraid of attacking and end up farming off their revenge list...

So true...be careful what you wish for!

Will add that of the 26 possible revenges on my def list, 11 are available right now. Am sure cup level may come into play on this, and am in m1. Just don't see the problem, is so much better than before the December update when everyone hid behind a shield at all times.
April 16th, 2016
shreyas16

Bad idea. Imagine If you have almost got enough loot for next upgrade and your collectors/mines/drills are about to collect enough loot for upgrade in an hour and you have nothing to care about.as you have 8h shield. Then suddenly someone attacks you and takes all your loot
April 16th, 2016
AyanD

Revenge should be allowed in Guard. After all, its just a small time.
April 16th, 2016
Zaneth98

Quote:

Originally Posted by plab

Methinks gemmers (aka whales) who pay for all those shields to stay in the upper leagues would be up in arms if this were the case. Not gonna happen.

Have you ever bought a shield? It has a cool down.