3 min is not enough

It's not enough. Period. I'm a th9. I have 3 starred many bases at 3min but with only 1 or 2 different strategies. This makes the game boring; making the same war attacks over and over again takes creativity out of troop compositions which gets old fast. I want to see more diversity in troop compositions. For the people that think th8 and th7 don't need more than 3min, I don't think your reasoning is sound. Most of the replies that I've seen, have been about th7s attacking other th7s and th8s attacking other th8s. If this was always the case in war, 3min would be perfect. However, that's not always how it works. I also have a th8 account and I've attacked many rushed th9s in war. Without the timer being set to 3:30, I can easily run out of time trying to take down extra defenses, archer queen etc. Also, if a th7 has to attack a th8 in war, then it's very hard to get the three star in under 3 min. And no, I don't believe anyone on this forum that says that they three star maxed th9s all the time, and it would be too easy to three star if there was more than 3 min. If you are three starring maxed th9s with ease every war, then your opponents consistently have the worst base layouts in clash of clans. It is hard to three star maxed th9s in 3 min. Anyone who says different is full of ♥♥♥♥. No one 3 stars every time no matter how much time they have to do it in.

Paragraphs.

Im sorry but we know,

There are thousands of post like these, all duplicates, just comment on one instead of making another thread

Also 3 mins ib ebough for TH9 and below 3.30 would be good for TH10, the game shouldnt be easy and if you mis time you should have attacked otherwise

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by trapperman

3 min is not enough

---

I'm sorry but I have to disagree with you and I apologize but I do not see a valid argument since TH9s and below were 3*ing before the December update. You have to realize that your enemy has the same 3 minutes as you and they have to deal with the clock as well. If you are failing and your enemy is successfully 3*ing, that is proof enough that 3 minutes is good enough and the problem is with the attacker.

If they make the game too easy for everyone else, the game will lose the challenge and become boring. This will cause more people to lose interest in the game and stop playing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TriStarCarnage

I'm sorry but I have to disagree with you and I apologize but I do not see a valid argument since TH9s and below were 3*ing before the December update. You have to realize that your enemy has the same 3 minutes as you and they have to deal with the clock as well. If you are failing and your enemy is successfully 3*ing, that is proof enough that 3 minutes is good enough and the problem is with the attacker.

If they make the game too easy for everyone else, the game will lose the challenge and become boring. This will cause more people to lose interest in the game and stop playing.

---

I guaranty you people have more fun getting three stars than 1-2.

It's a blast rolling a base for three. I loved the pre witch nerd era bc it gave causal players (like most of my current clan) an off chance of three starring 10s and 11s....the average person Can't (and I don't really know why bc it's tough but not that tough) three star with the more advanced tactics i.e. AQ walk, loons, hogs, mass pekka jump...that is still one that I have no clue how itd guys do it...bunnies or not....it's impressive...etc and I think there has been a dip in causal play since the update. I know my current clan, who are all either rl friends or relatives, has become much less active. We took a hit with the PBT but witches and warden really started energizing people once they saw what they had a chance to do.

I know the more serious players can and will adapt (I'm exploiting the hell out of valk/hog and valk/loon right now....I rip 11s apart faster and easier than with witches....but again, most people don't know how to work hogs high up) but the causal player base is what keeps a game going.

No one says they're 3 starring maxed TH9s "with ease". Plenty of people are capable of 3 starring maxed TH9s in under 3 minutes however.

Your argument for lower THs doesn't ring true either. It takes no longer for a TH7 with lvl 2 drags to 3 star a TH8 than it does for a TH8 with level 2 drags to 3 star the same base.

At TH10/11 there could be a case for reverting the time limit, but it is not needed for TH9 and below.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aspex

No one says they're 3 starring maxed TH9s "with ease". Plenty of people are capable of 3 starring maxed TH9s in under 3 minutes however.

Your argument for lower THs doesn't ring true either. It takes no longer for a TH7 with lvl 2 drags to 3 star a TH8 than it does for a TH8 with level 2 drags to 3 star the same base.

At TH10/11 there could be a case for reverting the time limit, but it is not needed for TH9 and below.

---

It DOES take longer. More structures to destroy, more hitpoints on those structures. A th7 hitting up DOES take longer. Lower spells, lower level dragons, lower-level king...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aspex

No one says they're 3 starring maxed TH9s "with ease". Plenty of people are capable of 3 starring maxed TH9s in under 3 minutes however.

.

---

I agree totally. Capable is the key word here. I would ask anyone who comments on the 3 mins to post their Hero levels too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Garmonbozia

It DOES take longer. More structures to destroy, more hitpoints on those structures. A th7 hitting up DOES take longer. Lower spells, lower level dragons, lower-level king...

---

Please explain how a base gains more structures and hit points when being attacked by a lower level TH.

I should have specified an early TH8 as the attacker to compare to, but thought that was a given as I did say they had lvl 2 drags.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Skrags

I agree totally. Capable is the key word here. I would ask anyone who comments on the 3 mins to post their Hero levels too.

---

On my 9, 29/27...last war I 3 starred 2 defensively maxed TH9s. A clanmate with 21/21 did likewise, one being in under 1'30".

My TH8 mini has plenty of 3 star attacks in matchmaking against low to mid 9s with a lvl 10 BK.