Originally Posted by
Lunaticfringe
Nope, I'm going to have to disagree with you. Mass hogs are likely the most consistent way to 3* at TH8. Once you get this/surgical attack strategy down, you will be well in excess of 90% 3* any/all max TH8 war bases. And I'm using 90% in an effort to be overly conservative
And I'd love to see a base that it doesn't work on, as you comment above
I think I found your problem, as well as a misconception.
You definitely have to think/plan for this attack/surgical to work best & you most definitely do adapt to each layout.
You also seem to be hung up on the attack morphing from fish/surgical to some other form of hog attack, but that's just silly; some adjustments tailored to the base is precisely what you want. Just because you might group hogs together at a certain point doesn't change it too much.
If you intention is to draw a delineation between fish and sirurgical, I suppose there might be. I'm technically a, "surgical" hog attacker, not necessarily a, "fish" hog attacker, but they strike me as similar. I roll my hogs around the base, fish gets them on the board very quickly. The end result, however, is very close...