Petition to remove preparation day COMPLETELY

+1 i vote valhalla!

Yea, i think that's kinda cool
But it would lost a little bit of the competition
But still, the idea of donate troops to ourself it would be pretty interesting!
:thumbsup:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Johnnyfsullivan

I like the idea and I'm in favor for warring more often (or having the ability to choose to war more often).

With respect to clan castle troops, I'm not sure how your proposal works with the game mechanics. perhaps it could be similar to current multiplayer mode. You fill the castle and it can be lost after an attack (you get a break period from being attacked so there is an opportunity to refill). Just thinking aloud, but regardless, I like the concept.

---

preparation day is needed to fill troops, fix war bases, and prepare war base, and fill war cc. Filling war cc is not a one man show, a=so no, but a reduction to 16 hours is more feasible.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by prosper12

preparation day is needed to fill troops, fix war bases, and prepare war base, and fill war cc. Filling war cc is not a one man show, a=so no, but a reduction to 16 hours is more feasible.

---

All reasonable questions but you obviously didn't read my first post, before writing it. Which is strange.

This idea is intriguing and I kinda like it. At first I was against the war troops automatically spawning in castles but at the same time we don't get anything at all for donating them so it makes sense to allow them to automatically spawn. But the coding should be made so that the highest level troops you could have can only be as high as the highest member in the war.

Also I think getting rid of prep day may work if war was extended a few hours. Add 6 more hours to war Making it 30 in total then keep like 2 hours before war for any last minute changes. That's still a net loss of 15 hours from the original 47 hour war days which would make it shorter.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by bpay27

This idea is intriguing and I kinda like it. At first I was against the war troops automatically spawning in castles but at the same time we don't get anything at all for donating them so it makes sense to allow them to automatically spawn. But the coding should be made so that the highest level troops you could have can only be as high as the highest member in the war.

Also I think getting rid of prep day may work if war was extended a few hours. Add 6 more hours to war Making it 30 in total then keep like 2 hours before war for any last minute changes. That's still a net loss of 15 hours from the original 47 hour war days which would make it shorter.

---

there are various possibilities to determine castle troops levels fairly. for instance, they can be capped at what that base has itself. if it doesn't have such troop opened it is capped at level1

You make a good argument. But for what it is worth, I disagree.

I don't use Gems... I jealousy hoard them and check back with the shop only to see how much my accumulation is now theoretically worth. Someday I hope to find a way to virtually swim in them like Scrooge McDuck. I only mention that because it takes me ALL DAY to fill the clan castles. Even with the latest update, I have to log in six to eight times throughout the day. I donate four dragons, four wizards, and four archers... do a raid for more potion to build more dragons... and then do it all over again after I've gone back to work for a couple hours. Maybe I could fill them all at once if I gemmed? It still seems like a stretch.

Then there are the days I don't have time to fill the war bases. Then we *definitely* need all day, because it takes that long for one of the other leaders to notice and do something about it. Sure, I could text one of them... but that would be unwilling volunteering them. Better to put a note on the clan chat and see whether anyone steps up. Even then, I do this all the time... someone else will take twice as long to fill them easy. Add in the different time zones... You really need that 23 hours to give every time zone a chance to log in once during their busy day... anything less and you'll have a ton of people who get no prep time at all.

I can see boredom of warring 3.5 times a week and the appeal of warring 7 times a week... but I also find the idea utterly terrifying. How is that going to affect the casual clans that only war once a week or less, that so many others are warring so frequently? Definitely don't have this casual clan's vote... for what it's worth!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Emaheevul

as far as prep, we have 1000's of war bases on file, we spend about an hour looking for the ones that our enemy uses and going from there, not much for prep day for us. People should really stop using posted internet bases IMO. Makes war easier for us.

In our war base files, we mark found bombs/traps, army comps and attack patterns, especially for 3 star. notes added to pics with a pic of the end of the attack for troop comp/level verification. I am surprised more people do not do this. It is the Fair Play version of bunny and completely within the ToS.

---

This sounds like a positively ridiculous amount of work. I am *not* surprised more people don't do this. I'm not surprised *someone* does it either... but I'd be utterly shocked if many clans under the top 1000 would even consider it. And I bet it's a significant minority among the top 1000 clans too! This is like... attack of the killer secretaries... or something.

:thumbsup: i support the idea and the troop you assign for defending are ur current level troops + the CC Level bonus (if they have). So low TH won't have much trouble dealing with high TH troops.

With the update pending prep day has become completly pointless my suggestion is that we still have a prep day and it still have a 23 hr clock on it however at the time both teams have completly filled all war cc war day begins!!!!!!😉