Printable View
My idea is that you could lock troops in donations/requests. What does it mean?
It means that if I dont want to have for example wallbreakers, so I could lock wallbreakers, so other players COULD NOT give me wallbreakers/other locked units. And also u could set level requirment for each unit for ex. +4 archers.
That would be a good idea, cuz not everyone reads the message. Always some1 stupid gives me wrong troops. If u agree plz tell me in comments ⬇
Why you so picky? Its free troops.
Nah I don't agree, if your mates are nice enough to give you troops, don't be that guy that locks out everything. Except pekka (or dragon or whatever)
Let me explain:Quote:
Originally Posted by AgeofWarriors
donation is always free troops, no matter if the troops are locked or not, free troops. I just said it would be easier. And in real life if I asked my mate to give me a pen (if he wants to give) and he gives me a ruler (which I dont need/I have already),I dont need/want it. In real life I wouldnt take it (maybe throw it in a trash bin if he forces me to take it anyways), but in CoC I must take all troops, even the wrong troops. Thats silly cuz I have to waste my time for wasting the wrong troops in (for example) single player mission (just attack with troops then end battle/surrender). And I also have to wait for 20 mins before requesting again. And the most bad thing is that the stupid clanmate will get donations in the list (and I will get recieves) just making the things worse!
PS.
If I need only a PEKKA, then I should get PEKKA, not (for ex.) 25 goblins. If they dont want to give me a PEKKA, then they shouldnt give me anything. To have nothing is better than wrong troops!!!
PS.2.
This idea would fix that! Thats why I suggested it! Think avout that!
I doubt that there should be any fixing other than your clan member... Try to find members that is serious and doesn't donate only for exp... I'm on a great clan and we have good communication so the donation process runs very smoothly.... And now you can customised the message.. If they don't get the message and donate different troop anyway then the problem is with the members.
It's unnecessary i think because it will be a new function and it maybe hard to implement (code).... You'd be better of trying to communicate or change clan...
Your eliminating potential donations.
Say for example no one online has what you want. How disheartening that you see your clan mates requests filled around you and your still waiting for your certain troop.
A much easier way is get a decent clan with decent members that you can say
Hey can you make me a dragon for my next request and liaise with them to donate as you request.
Worked for us the last year ! Even without custom request message.
In real life you could throw it away. In CoC, it's simple, give it to the goblins in single player. And some people will abuse the power to lock troops and only get those super expensive troops. What about those startup clans. How are they gonna survive?Quote:
Originally Posted by labaownage
I have said what I think, cant explain better. Its nice to read ur comments: critics & good things. Just hope that supercell staff will notice this thread & write it on "to do list" if possible.
What happens if a level 16 in a clan of 3 people (low levels too) request and lock all the troops except golems. How do you think is the clan going to work and if you locked everything except golems and no one gives you then next time you request you forget to change it, you get 0 troops. Whereas in messages attached to your requests, if you forgot to change it, you can tell your clanmates that you wrote it wrong but if you locked everything except golems how are you going to change it?! People will want the golems and the clan won't be good. I'm not saying this is a bad idea.
I would like the request timer to be reduced or completely removed, theres nothing more annoying then when you ask for archers and recieve goblins and wallbreakers level 1's
atleast if the clan castle had either no timer or a lower timer after use you could at least try again and hopefully get what you wanted.
also they'll lock everyhting eexpat for the goodies, that they can't even fitQuote:
Originally Posted by XLR8
Why are you guys saying stuff like "low-levels will lock everything but golems"? You don't gain anything by locking out everything but dragons if your clan doesn't have dragons to begin with, they'll only hurt themselves. I like the idea, it helps with silly mistakes (accidentally donating a goblin when trying to tap archers) and gives players who donate dragons or PEKKAs (I have a few in my clan that do so often) a chance to, something that they often can't do because other clan mates are too quick to donate 5 silly archers and take up the space...
The concept is good if you set limits, instead of maybe locking out units maybe select a unit you prefer that will reward donors with bonus exp. or place an exp. penalty for donating an unwanted troop?