If you click on your name within this thread (or any thread) you can see all the posts you have made.
You can also view your posts by going to
my profile up at the top (right) and clicking on your name under
my activity.
I was adding that link for quick reference for readers and to also provide a link to what I had commented previously about tartar sauce, in case you or another forum-member wanted to visit the thread and read through the responses there.
When I comment on posts in the IFR section, I either am:
--pointing out the existence of the must read sticky
--agreeing with the idea
--disagreeing with the idea
--offering some additional information that might not have been realized when the suggestion was made
So, no, I am not getting some "big thrill" in criticizing your ideas and suggestions.
I
am trying to offer some guidance. I gather from some of your posts and threads that you are still trying to learn the ropes of the game. I am just trying to (gently, what I assumed to be gentle, at least) assist in aiding you with that. You've asked questions and I and others have answered your questions. Either you saw them and read them and did not reply or you have yet to go back and read your threads. I know you asked some questions in General that were answered.
In your threads, I offered my own opinions of the your suggestions. I feel my comments offered constructive criticism. I too play the game and I felt it necessary to chime in with what I would like to see from SC. I suppose I see SC differently from you, in that I feel a portion of the ideas here are indeed fair game for them to implement. :)
In your threads, I also offered some additional information regarding levels and how things might not work as clear-cut as previously thought. There are a lot of ideas given but sometimes there is more to consider (not just with your ideas, but others as well). I was trying to offer some information you might not have, in case you are not at that level yet.
Also, I have been on the forum for about 3 years so I have read a lot of opinions and gotten a bit of an idea as to the likes and dislikes. Stuff like machines getting changed likely won't fly over well (unless it's
changing back the soup machine to the original soup machine ;)). So sometimes, I am also offering input on previous things I have read on here. I try and note such a thing, as needed. I did that in the post you quoted.
Additionally, for the record, I have agreed with some of your ideas in the past.
SC collects ideas on a weekly basis:
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...SUBMIT-AN-IDEA
Players wanted bees and honey for a long time and we got that. Because we got bees, we got beeswax. I had seen requests for beeswax and candles as well, so those were both put into the game.
I saw people request clothes too for awhile and then we got the sewing machine. Speaking of clothes, I just remembered you asked for overalls once. I can't recall if I replied to that, but I like your overalls idea a lot. I really hope that makes it in the game.
There's been non-building and non-production machine ideas get implemented in the game as well.
I think this might also be of interest to you. Nick explained a little bit about the design process:
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...=1#post6804334
Additionally, you might want to read the description of a Game Specialist. That can be found here:
http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/722501-Game-Specialists