Restrict spy's during WAR

Every clan would like to start war and wish to win always. All those clans don't have the 50 people. So they will recruit people always. It makes the enemy clan to go for a cheap idea. That is the clan member will leave the clan and join the enemy clan and take take screenshots of all the bases and join back their own clan. So they can see all the traps and plan their attacks with respect to the bases.
So, there is an idea to restrict them. If a person joining a clan while preparation or war day HE/SHE SHOULD BE RESTRICTED TO TAP CLAN WAR BUTTON UNTIL THE CURRENT WAR gets finished. It could be helpful to restrict the spy's.

Simple solution:

Check the clan and remember all the names or something like that.
Also use fake bases untill the last minute.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by saibalaj

Every clan would like to start war and wish to win always. All those clans don't have the 50 people. So they will recruit people always. It makes the enemy clan to go for a cheap idea. That is the clan member will leave the clan and join the enemy clan and take take screenshots of all the bases and join back their own clan. So they can see all the traps and plan their attacks with respect to the bases.
So, there is an idea to restrict them. If a person joining a clan while preparation or war day HE/SHE SHOULD BE RESTRICTED TO TAP CLAN WAR BUTTON UNTIL THE CURRENT WAR gets finished. It could be helpful to restrict the spy's.

---

Why? I send spies to the clans, it's like in real wars.. If the clan is open, it's easy, if is "invite only" and someone accepts it's problem of that clan.

What I do to prevent me from that is to close the clan or increase a lot the trophies. The people that come in need invitation, so if someone of my clan accept that people, the problem is in my clan. All the elder and co already knows, during the war nobody come in by self-invitation (this is clan organization problem..)

Here's my Idea on this:

So Clan War has begun, lets say between Clan A and B. Clan members (ie All members, not just the War participants) of A will not be able to join B until war ends, they would be restricted, unable to send request in case of Invite only. They would however be able to join other clans, just not the opponent Clan in the War. This would work both ways.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marticco

Here's my Idea on this:

So Clan War has begun, lets say between Clan A and B. Clan members (ie All members, not just the War participants) of A will not be able to join B until war ends, they would be restricted, unable to send request in case of Invite only. They would however be able to join other clans, just not the opponent Clan in the War. This would work both ways.

---

As I said, if the spy can enter the clan is because: 1) Clan is open to everyone. 2) Somebody accepted him
So the problem is bad clan organization.

The "position of spy" should be a feature, I close my clan during wars or increase a lot the trophies, so only people join by clan-invitation and not by self-invite.

Sorry my bad english :p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 3runinho

As I said, if the spy can enter the clan is because: 1) Clan is open to everyone. 2) Somebody accepted him
So the problem is bad clan organization.

The "position of spy" should be a feature, I close my clan during wars or increase a lot the trophies, so only people join by clan-invitation and not by self-invite.

Sorry my bad english :p

---

As i said, People from Clan A would not be able to join B even if it was Open, in this case a new system would be worked out by Supercell to prevent A from joining B. Bad Clan Organisation? Answer me this, if your clan had war everyday how would you get more members if you Closed you Clan during war as you say?. From you opinion, you have a window where new people can come to clan, mostly 45 mins maximum ie while searching for war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MagicTownie

Simple solution:

Check the clan and remember all the names or something like that.
Also use fake bases untill the last minute.

---

We can do that. But still they can use their other accounts. And also they can join on battle day and can see all those traps. Most of the clans don't have full capacity. So they need to recruit people always to strengthen the clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marticco

Here's my Idea on this:

So Clan War has begun, lets say between Clan A and B. Clan members (ie All members, not just the War participants) of A will not be able to join B until war ends, they would be restricted, unable to send request in case of Invite only. They would however be able to join other clans, just not the opponent Clan in the War. This would work both ways.

---

This is also a good idea. But still they can use their other accounts to spy the enemy clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 3runinho

Why? I send spies to the clans, it's like in real wars.. If the clan is open, it's easy, if is "invite only" and someone accepts it's problem of that clan.

What I do to prevent me from that is to close the clan or increase a lot the trophies. The people that come in need invitation, so if someone of my clan accept that people, the problem is in my clan. All the elder and co already knows, during the war nobody come in by self-invitation (this is clan organization problem..)

---

Every clan will love wars. So if a war finishes they will start the next war as soon as possible. So it could not be a good idea to keep clan closed during wars. And also if a person is chatting in global the person who is not in a clan may send request without chatting with them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 3runinho

As I said, if the spy can enter the clan is because: 1) Clan is open to everyone. 2) Somebody accepted him
So the problem is bad clan organization.

The "position of spy" should be a feature, I close my clan during wars or increase a lot the trophies, so only people join by clan-invitation and not by self-invite.

Sorry my bad english :p

---

I am looking for a system to stop this. Like if a person is in war they cant join war in other clan.

Close the clan during war simple as that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marticco

As i said, People from Clan A would not be able to join B even if it was Open, in this case a new system would be worked out by Supercell to prevent A from joining B. Bad Clan Organisation? Answer me this, if your clan had war everyday how would you get more members if you Closed you Clan during war as you say?. From you opinion, you have a window where new people can come to clan, mostly 45 mins maximum ie while searching for war.

---

Most of the clans like to start the WAR as soon as the current one finishes. As marticco said it can't be a bad clan organization at all. Because still the enemy clan players to use their fake accounts to spy the enemy clan. However it would be good to restrict player's to tap clan war button if a clan is ina war. It can be either preparation or war day. That is if a war begins, the players at the time of war searching alone can be allowed to access clan war button.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kaizer27

Close the clan during war simple as that.

---

If a clan is doing war always when the CLAN will look for members? Only before starting the WAR alone! I don't think it could be a good idea.

The clan can still invite members, and choose who they want.. Even if clan it's closed..

In this moment I'm in another clan spying with an account that isn't in war, so.. What was the problem? The clan accepted somebody that sent invite "from the sky"..

You are in a global chat and post about your clan recruitment. At that time the net got disconnected. Then how do know the people sent request on their own or from your post. Global chat always closes whenever the game restarts again. Also why we need to close the CLAN always and send invite on global chat to everyone who don't have a clan. Instead if it is invite only, you can just post a message about your clan and the requirements. Just look for simple solution.

I look the members information, if he left clan in war, the number of donates, war stars, and if I like, I invite or ask if he want to join. Only 1 or 2 times , the game disconnected when I was in global, maybe I'm lucky

Sorry for my bad english