New way to deal with members disobeying 'clan rules' in clan war.

Hi, this is my first post so please be gentle.

I've been playing COC for almost 3 years now and 1 year Leader of a level 9 clan. Managing a clan is not easy especially a clan who always goes to war. The problem I've been experiencing recently is members who don't follow our clan rules in clan war. Attacking base stronger than the attacker who aims just to get 1 star just to get a higher war loot bonus while other members try to get 3 star in lower numbers securing the clan win at the end.

So my suggestion is giving the leader the right to expell members who joins clan war for their personal gain. Leader have another option in expelling members, if the said member is currently participating in war, there should be an option to limit the war loot he/she will get. Like 1/5 of total war loot bonus or nothing at all. If you guys wondering if Clan Leaders will abuse this feature, I highly doubt it. From the perspective of a leader, It grealty benefits me coz I want my members who joins in war for the clan instead of themselves. And I'm sure no one will expell members who is good at attacking in war.

I got an idea how you can implement this. The said punishment should last equally to 'Eligible to war in' plus 1 hour cause I notice that 'Eligible in war' is shorter than the end of war.

Any violent reaction is accepted and sorry for my english. Its not my native language.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by crow082

Hi, this is my first post so please be gentle.

I've been playing COC for almost 3 years now and 1 year Leader of a level 9 clan. Managing a clan is not easy especially a clan who always goes to war. The problem I've been experiencing recently is members who don't follow our clan rules in clan war. Attacking base stronger than the attacker who aims just to get 1 star just to get a higher war loot bonus while other members try to get 3 star in lower numbers securing the clan win at the end.

So my suggestion is giving the leader the right to expell members who joins clan war for their personal gain. Leader have another option in expelling members, if the said member is currently participating in war, there should be an option to limit the war loot he/she will get. Like 1/5 of total war loot bonus or nothing at all. If you guys wondering if Clan Leaders will abuse this feature, I highly doubt it. From the perspective of a leader, It grealty benefits me coz I want my members who joins in war for the clan instead of themselves. And I'm sure no one will expell members who is good at attacking in war.

I got an idea how you can implement this. The said punishment should last equally to 'Eligible to war in' plus 1 hour cause I notice that 'Eligible in war' is shorter than the end of war.

Any violent reaction is accepted and sorry for my english. Its not my native language.

---

I know now my leader would find doing that funny and war costs a lot with the higher level troops. I think getting a refund of troops cost and no war loot would be better.

Welcome to the forums!

I think that you have a good idea here. You are on to something, but I think it needs a little tweaking.

all clans have the same problem of having people disobey the recommended target given by the clan, especially the new members. we have a system that works very well with us: we dont take many new members at once to war unless they have proven to be military assets and not liabilities; so that even if they get it wrong it will not ruin the war. we kick after almost every war, and recruit new members again, and kick again: it is called CLAN MAINTENANCE

Leaders could enforce this punishment for many other reasons, since nothing is stopping them. Gotta find some more ways to keep the leader's power in check.

In my opinion, as a level 9 war clan, I'm assuming you guys are incredibly serious about war, and I'm assuming you hate these people. To me, as a serious war clan, instead of increasing a leader's power, I would simply kick the player that is fooling around out, and take the coleaders and create a blacklist-like document [something on Google Drive or an email list or something]. Basically any coleader or leader should be added to this document where they can see names of different COC players that are "banned" from the clan. This way, you take the stupid players out, and you never let them back in. It's a problem that can be easily solved.