Clan wars

Could we have clan wars ?
Clan members could have donate to war tab on own clan castle which can hold up to 250 people between all clan members. Then when 250 donations have been put in castle it could be entered automatically in to a clan war with another clan where win outcome would be based on best army. We could then have an option to watch a replay of that match. You could just set it on an open battlefield, maybe look at doing clan wars with up to 4 clans with 250 army each.
Anyone like the sound of this ?
Winnings could be a set amount for all matches shared between all clan members even if they didn't donate to the war.

I like the idea of clan wars. I've thought up something a little more detailed tho.

There would be a "battlefield" that is the same in area as the area in which you build your village. Battles would be 1v1. Battling clans would each be given 1/2 of the field divided in the middle. Each clan would have only a town hall. The clan leader place this wherever they want on their half of the field. The levels of the town halls would be based on the average lvls of the clan members town Halls rounded down.

The clan leader would be able to decide who to go to war with. Only clans with the same level Town Hall may attack each other. Once war has been declared, no other clans may declare war upon either of the 2 battling clans. The clans would then be given a 12hour grace period to donate "x" troops (depending on the number supercell would decide if this happens. Also this would be based on housing space, not the number of units). After the 12 hours the battle would start.

The troops would come out of the Town Hall just like they come out of your clan castle to protect your village. The units would come out in the order they were put into the castle (creating slight strategy and clan coordination) over a span of about 2 minutes and 15 seconds, leaving the final 45 seconds for the troops to finish fighting. When all troops are dead or someones Town Hall is destroyed, the battle is over. The clan who inflicted the most damage to their Town Hall, or maybe even last man standing is the winner.

The resource winnings would be a % win. A certain % of the losers resources would be taken (maybe 5 or 10%) and equally given to each clan member of the winning clan.
Trophies would also be divided equally between the members of the winning clan. Athough, the trophies may not be a % win, but rather similar to how trophies are already won. If a clan declares war on someone with less trophies than them, they would win less than if they attacked someone at a similar trophy level.

Both clans would then be granted a "clan shield" essentially so that other clans cannot immediately declare war against them, but if a clan chooses to attack another clan and get rid of their shield, they may.

I think thats pretty much it. Let me know what you think please.

I have had almost the same idea yesterday and I wanted to propose it today. I wish this proposal will be taken into account in 2013 !

Ive revised it a little. The clan leader shouldnt be able to place the building wherever. I'm not sure if it would even affect the outcome of a battle, but this would allow for equal playing fields for both teams.

Also, I decided the average level of the town halls should probably round up, otherwise there probably wouldn't be any clans with level 9 Town Halls.

check the sticky at the top of the forum - this is being considered ya de ya

I saw that actually. I just wanted to post this still to put a simple way of doing these clan wars and how the winnings/losings could work. I'm not saying they have to use this or anything, but if they're considering making it, it wouldn't hurt to have people post ideas about how they could do it as suggestions or a base idea to work from.

I would say 2 min for troops comimg out of the castle, and then 3 min battle. Also i would make it possible to place walls, and other defence in the battle field. That way you would have to donate gold to build defence. At the end each member of the winning team will get 10 gems. If every member leaves the clan then the battle will be canceled.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Deathstorm01

I would say 2 min for troops comimg out of the castle, and then 3 min battle. Also i would make it possible to place walls, and other defence in the battle field. That way you would have to donate gold to build defence. At the end each member of the winning team will get 10 gems. If every member leaves the clan then the battle will be canceled.

---

I said 2 min and 15 seconds with battle time of 45 seconds so that they could keep it to 3 minute battles, just like all other battles. Supercell can have the units spawn at whatever speed they like, I just thought itd be easier for them to keep it at a standard time.

At first I thought defences would be good too, but if there are defences, after all the units kill each other the defences will just finish off the remaining units and theres a possibility that no damage could be dealt to oppenents buildings. So I dont think there should be any defence structures since both clans would be on equal playing fields if both clans only have the Town Hall.

And as much as I would love to be rewarded for attacking and winning in clan battles, I don't think supercell should be the one's rewarding us with gems. The resources and trophies that would be stolen from the losing clan should be enough to want you to have clan battles.

Instead of a big open field, clans should be able to build a clan city together. Clan elders can collaboratively build a village up from zero. The buildings can look slightly different from the regular village buildings and have slightly different properties. Clan members donate gold, elix, troops and gems to build the city. There are no barracks to train troops, which must be donated by clan members. Keep the attack concept and the troop donation the same as is suggested in this forum.

Clan members can buy gems to donate to the city, or to make resources or troops to donate to the city.

This would let Supercell make money and give it a ton more options for development than if clan wars were just a big open space where people dropped the existing troop units.

A big open space with only troops will create one main problem. There is no opportunity for game development. Players donate troops. That's it. It'd be like the arena fights in Castle Crash, which get pretty boring quickly. Clan Wars, instead, should give you the opportunity to build. After all, that's the compulsive factor that has made the game so popular in the first place.