Loot cart amendment

Hello everyone,
I really appreciate the new loot cart feature and I think 20% is a reasonable fraction of refunding. In spite of this, a part for massive loot losses, the difference it makes is hardly noticeable. In my opinion, the cart system would make more sense if the refunded loot was stored in the treasury instead of deposits. It will sound like "Hey we managed to retrieve these resources back, let's make sure we don't loose them again!" and it will make "every little helps". What do you think about it?

Since we are talking about compensation for lost defences, I'm sure someone already proposed this but, wouldn't be nicer to have the resources stored in the gravestones to be proportional to the unit base cost (or just type). I'm not talking about big amounts, but still, if you managed to kill a pekka you should get rewarded a bit more respect to a barbarian.

Looking forward to hear all the reasons my suggestions will be unbalanced I didn't think about.
Peace,
Balthazar

I fully agree, loot cart should be stored in treasury when collected.
And for the troop RSS, I agree too and think maybe 2% of the killed troops value would be fair.

FocusedGods, RockyJoeHawkins, Co-Leader, TH10,

Completely agree. It would also make up for the loot lost from the treasury during defences

SC originally thought this, but finally decided to let it transfer to storage instead of treasury for unknown reason. Although, I'm not sure if 20% is significant considering master league and up is getting dry of loot; perhaps 50% loot cart refund will be nice...

Yup, great idea. Also we should get a 100% refund from loot cart instead of 20%.

It would be nice if the loot cart when into the treasury so players had the choice of leaving it there or moving it their storages.

I also like the idea of getting a small percentage of troops killed back instead of a fixed number regardless of unit cost. Anything to help inject some elixir into the economy gets my :thumbsup:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lavablast

Yup, great idea. Also we should get a 100% refund from loot cart instead of 20%.

---

♥♥♥♥. May I assume this is sarcasm? OR...is your idea that defending is now unnecessary....ever?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RockyJoeHawkins

I fully agree, loot cart should be stored in treasury when collected.
And for the troop RSS, I agree too and think maybe 2% of the killed troops value would be fair.

FocusedGods, RockyJoeHawkins, Co-Leader, TH10,

---

That would make more sense, so you can save it when you need it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DrSalvador

SC originally thought this, but finally decided to let it transfer to storage instead of treasury for unknown reason. Although, I'm not sure if 20% is significant considering master league and up is getting dry of loot; perhaps 50% loot cart refund will be nice...

---

U know how easy losing trophies in purpose right... 50% is way too many :s

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DrSalvador

SC originally thought this, but finally decided to let it transfer to storage instead of treasury for unknown reason. Although, I'm not sure if 20% is significant considering master league and up is getting dry of loot; perhaps 50% loot cart refund will be nice...

---

Well, I think 20% is alright. After all, loosing a defence should still be something to be concerned. I'm proposing this modification to increase the treasury usefulness. I'm a farmer TH 10, who has to stay in silver to earn decently and does not many war (most of which lost). Given the typical time scale of "farming resources --> Build", which is less than a week, there is no time to accumulate any decent amount in the treasury. I usually have few hundred k when I lunch a new building so the treasury protective purpose, and its contribution to my economy, is really low. What I'm suggesting won't change drastically the treasury income rate, but maybe it will help low league player with little income from wars.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Balthazar89

Well, I think 20% is alright. After all, loosing a defence should still be something to be concerned. I'm proposing this modification to increase the treasury usefulness. I'm a farmer TH 10, who has to stay in silver to earn decently and does not many war (most of which lost). Given the typical time scale of "farming resources --> Build", which is less than a week, there is no time to accumulate any decent amount in the treasury. I usually have few hundred k when I lunch a new building so the treasury protective purpose, and its contribution to my economy, is really low. What I'm suggesting won't change drastically the treasury income rate, but maybe it will help low league player with little income from wars.

---

100% refund or nothing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lavablast

100% refund or nothing.

---

Lol, I assume you are trolling, sir

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Balthazar89

Lol, I assume you are trolling, sir

---

That's much more than just trolling.
That's sarcasm.

Yup, totally agree. Also while we're at it, maybe we should make it 200% refund from attacks. I also think we should get rid of defenses and remove the attacking option. The clan feature is terrible too. :smirk::smirk::smirk::smirk::smirk:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by calebMcF

Yup, totally agree. Also while we're at it, maybe we should make it 200% refund from attacks. I also think we should get rid of defenses and remove the attacking option. The clan feature is terrible too. :smirk::smirk::smirk::smirk::smirk:

---

Well...I don't think I have proposed something so bad to attract all this sarcasm upon me. Why would that be bad in your mind?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Balthazar89

Well...I don't think I have proposed something so bad to attract all this sarcasm upon me. Why would that be bad in your mind?

---

Make it 300% instead actually.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Balthazar89

Well...I don't think I have proposed something so bad to attract all this sarcasm upon me. Why would that be bad in your mind?

---

Don't take it too seriously. :)

You should be rewarded for having good defenses.

To be honest i would rather have it in my storages, but i guess we could have a choice

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TBag13

To be honest i would rather have it in my storages, but i guess we could have a choice

---

Yeah, you can always transfer it to your storages if it pleases you

sorry this doesn't relate to this thread but how do you make a poll in a thread?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cocthinkengine

I agree with 50% of total unit cost should be in the loot cart

---

Well, this isn't quite what I was suggesting...

Stop talking about 50 % refunds. They're not gonna happen.

I think it should just be the amount of the available loot that they DON'T get. Rewards you for defense. If they take it all you get nothing cause your got mauled. BUT, if they don't get much then BAM! Makes more sense to me than any arbitrary percentage.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RockyJoeHawkins

I fully agree, loot cart should be stored in treasury when collected.
And for the troop RSS, I agree too and think maybe 2% of the killed troops value would be fair.

FocusedGods, RockyJoeHawkins, Co-Leader, TH10,

---

Yep, all the way!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by west77au

I think it should just be the amount of the available loot that they DON'T get. Rewards you for defense. If they take it all you get nothing cause your got mauled. BUT, if they don't get much then BAM! Makes more sense to me than any arbitrary percentage.

---

Have you ever been attacked by a single barbarian from people going down in league? Is it still a fair situation?