active war base set to random

we have now 3 war bases.
one we set active for during war.
one we use for pre-building the next level or incremental level improvements (call it OCD).
one we otherwise use for during preparation day to 'hide' our actual war base (brag layout?).
why that last use? because some teams really prepare on that day - researching the enemy -- and to keep some small degree of honesty, we jump thru hoops to hide our real war base.

in truth, we have perfectly ready 3 war bases, but only one really gets a workout.
its a problem that some clans 'game' the war and by their second attack on a base, its over in that war.
there are more concerns, but my clan has already raised them. i am only looking for a simplified solution.
why not allow an edit mode option -- to set the 'active' war base selection to 'random'.

i like all 3 layouts, like a parent loves their children equally -- and want to see them all in action.
i also like to see that our enemies can try more times to really win off the 3 stars from our bases (& us off them).
personally, i would alternate between a ground, an air and a mixed defensive setup.

Just switch them manually, I don't see why this is needed to be honest.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

Just switch them manually, I don't see why this is needed to be honest.

---

I am referring to within the course of a single war. After each defense, randomly change layout chosen. Other clan can see,wht not, but at least not have used first attack to perfect second one. This does not exist....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rollerDisco

I am referring to within the course of a single war. After each defense, randomly change layout chosen. Other clan can see,wht not, but at least not have used first attack to perfect second one. This does not exist....

---

Oh. Well that would destroy cleanup strategies so I don't see this happening, sorry.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

Oh. Well that would destroy cleanup strategies so I don't see this happening, sorry.

---

Perhaps i should justify more then.

We plan our first attacks carefully on prep day. It is 24 hr window. Then, importance returns to our first attack.

Cleanup. Immediately after being attacked, reset layout and let other clan see that. Then, they have balance of war to plan a new attack plan. This is still a clean up, if your first go did not 3 star.

This is opposite the 2nd run being 100% certain 3 star, as happens to us against clans that practice between 1st and 2nd how to defeat exactly your frozen layout.

War feels boring now that we all strive to 3 star all th9 and lower, every one, every time. Your way, not even the hidden defenses move.

Cleanup becomes about recoordinating, not just a simple, optimized 2nd attack.

Think of my way as a rebuild. Then you can see a return to 2 years ago, when some random design mid tier base could go undefeated after 8-10 attack defenses.

If random is too much, make it cycle. At least then try to see a cleanup from 4th defense on.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rollerDisco

Perhaps i should justify more then.

We plan our first attacks carefully on prep day. It is 24 hr window. Then, importance returns to our first attack.

Cleanup. Immediately after being attacked, reset layout and let other clan see that. Then, they have balance of war to plan a new attack plan. This is still a clean up, if your first go did not 3 star.

This is opposite the 2nd run being 100% certain 3 star, as happens to us against clans that practice between 1st and 2nd how to defeat exactly your frozen layout.

War feels boring now that we all strive to 3 star all th9 and lower, every one, every time. Your way, not even the hidden defenses move.

Cleanup becomes about recoordinating, not just a simple, optimized 2nd attack.

Think of my way as a rebuild. Then you can see a return to 2 years ago, when some random design mid tier base could go undefeated after 8-10 attack defenses.

If random is too much, make it cycle. At least then try to see a cleanup from 4th defense on.

---

randomizing traps which targetted in preperation will be better so they still called traps, even tho for base its set in preperation so its meant to ready for the war, but with these lame mod thats used by many people random traps will be great xD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jackylucas

randomizing traps which targetted in preperation will be better so they still called traps, even tho for base its set in preperation so its meant to ready for the war, but with these lame mod thats used by many people random traps will be great xD

---

Thank you. This is another way to use this same idea, by making only edits to traps between 3 available layouts. Gives excellent reason to keep 'copy' function.