When clicking on the enemy war base, we should see the attack history right there. Finding all attacks in the 'War Events' tab is cumbersome.
Printable View
When clicking on the enemy war base, we should see the attack history right there. Finding all attacks in the 'War Events' tab is cumbersome.
I don't think this is really needed, especially since usually the best attack will reveal most or all of the traps or important information.
However, it does make where can see all attacks.Quote:
Originally Posted by Radiating
Sometimes, reviewing attacks, is not just to see traps, but leaders evaluating the member's attacks.
There is no point of this being implemented.
Good idea tho :D
Of course there is a point! If I'm doing a ground raid, and the best attack is air, the replay doesn't help me much. Besides, I probably want to watch all replays anyway.
I'm not debating this point, I'm on a debate team, I do my debating there. I don't need this to steer into some off-topic thing, it's not worth my time. BUT, This point isn't true simply because the attack history allows one to see every attack that's been made already, and this doesn't.Quote:
Originally Posted by BurkeKnight
Yes, if you want to dig through all the attacks to find them all. And then inevitably you will end up watching the same attack again mistakenly then have to dig through the log again. It's a small thing I'm asking for that would making studying for a clean-up attack easier.
Okay, then how would this appear on the base screen?Quote:
Originally Posted by speakers
When on the war map and you click on a base, there are currently three options: replay, attack, and scout. I am suggessting that this UI get modified to show all attacks on that base. It could be a button that, when pressed, displays a popup form with the attack history. If that doesn't work for some reason, I'm sure the devs can figure out a way that works.
No, the war map is cumbersome and redundant.Quote:
Originally Posted by speakers
Instead, replays should be accessible not just from the "War Events" tab. In large wars, it is very tedious to search through that long (up to 200) chronological list to find the attack you want to watch.
Battle replays should be available from the 3rd and 4th tabs, "My Team" and "Enemy Team", from both the Attacks and Defences reports. These are the locations to find, in a logical format, all battle results. If the attacks were linked to replays, it would facilitate nicely reviewing a particular players attacks, and every base's worst defeat, as per the existing format.
Not a bad way to do it George. Thanks for the input.
I was thinking about this some more. I still think on the image of the base there should be an info button with a popup that displays all of the defenses on that base. Furthermore, after you watch a replay, there should be a next and previous button so we can scroll through the different attacks.
It's a good idea. Just need to nail out the details. Last war for example I wanted to copy a queen walk that one of the other members had planned out. His raid wasn't the best as he caked his surgical hogs. But the walk was perfect. So I needed to know the exact tile he dropped his queen on and the timing of the troops used to funnel her. I then had to check another replay (still not the top attack) to confirm a dgb location.
edit: Georges idea seems to work.
WE DID IT! YAY!!!! The update will do this idea using George's method, so thanks again for the input George!