Donations

Hi,
I see some difficulty in properly handle donations, especially in numerous clan it happens that more than one player creates troops for the same donation and often no one knows who is thinking about a specific request of troops. Maybe it could be useful to book a donation through a specific command, this would allow the clan to see that I'm doing the troops for a specific donation. At the end it's important that the clan could see something like "Pol has booked this donation."
Thanks for your attention.

Think this reservation should expire after 45 minutes. Other than that, I think this is a bit redundant. What does this solve for that we can't already do right now?

Probably I was not clear, I try to make an example:
there are two players who see a request for troops and both begin to create them. A third player enters in the game, sees the same request and has troops available so he gives them immediately. The result is that the other two players will have in the their camps some troops unnecessary. The solution that I am proposing is to book a specific donation (the reservation will expire after 45 minutes), and when the troops will be ready, they will be automatically donated without making any other action. We are in a clan of 10 members and we have a lot of confusion, especially during the wars, we entering and leaving the game to donate or check if there are new requests for troops and this is stressful, I can imagine what happens in the clan of 40/50 people !
I think that this little idea could be the solution to this issue.
Thank you for your attention.

I don't think this should be implemented. Lets say that a player requests troops for war, and he has to attack now. If someone books it for fun, then no one can donate for 45 mins. and that could affect the war outcome (maybe not).

The booking of the donation is only a way to show to the others players of the clan who is doing what and to whom. Even if a player sees that a donation is booked, it can still decide to give his troops, in this case the "linked" troops of the other player will be automatically canceled. The booking of the donations should make the game fast and efficient and allow automatic donations reducing the need to access continuously and avoid confusion.
Let me know your impressions.
Thank you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Radiating

Think this reservation should expire after 45 minutes. Other than that, I think this is a bit redundant. What does this solve for that we can't already do right now?

---

Sorry but I didn't understand if you think this could be usefull or not, have you read the other details that i wrote?
Let me know your impressions.
Thank you.

As soon as a donation request pops up why not just reply on the chat stating that you will deal with the request?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rue73

As soon as a donation request pops up why not just reply on the chat stating that you will deal with the request?

---

This is what we are doing, we are writing something like "I'm creating the troops for this player" but unfortunately it happen that someone begins to create the troops and forgets them or he exits from the game and disappears... Sometimes some player want to attack immediately and he asks the troops to another player even if he knows that another player is creating troops for him, there are a lot of examples like this. The solution that I'm proposing is very easy and each troop is linked to a specific donation, you don't have to enter into the game so many times to check if your troops are ready or not, it's all authomatic.
I hope to have been clear.
Thank you